Year: 2020
Type: dissertation
Abstract: In this dissertation, I explore public attitudes toward immigration in the United States and Britain, focusing on several controversies in the literature. First, voters in industrial democracies diverge in terms of preferences for immigration policies while agreeing about what kinds of immigrants should be admitted. Second, the literature identifies sociotropic threats as the key predictor of opinions on immigration, but individual differences in threat perception remain unexplained. Third, studies disagree on the role of immigrants’ race/ethnicity in sparking anti-immigration backlash. To address these controversies, I rely on the schematic model of political cognition. It postulates that, in order to form attitudes toward political categories people connect them to familiar concepts and attributes. Schemas are mental connections linking different categories and/or attributes in memory. Individual differences in schemas about “who the immigrants are,” therefore, predict whether immigration is perceived as more or less harmful. Due to measurement challenges, the application of the schematic model in political science has been limited: people are unable to assess or unwilling to admit the degree to which schemas influence their political preferences. In my dissertation, I address these methodological challenges by developing two original unobtrusive measurement instruments for individual-level schemas about political categories based, respectively, on the implicit association test (IAT) and conjoint experiments. In Chapter II, I review the basic tenets of the schematic model and develop a new objective timed-response measure of group schemas in politics based on the IAT architecture. The measure proves valid in two empirical studies examining schematic links between social groups and political objects. In Study 1, gender–party schemas impact respondents’ feelings towards the two major parties in the United States. In Study 2, I revisit the “racialization of welfare” hypothesis, finding that race–poverty schemas are related to support for income redistribution. In Chapter III, I hypothesize that there is variation in the degree to which natives think of immigrants in racial terms, and that this variation has implications for attitudes toward immigration. Using original surveys carried out in the United States and Britain, I demonstrate that, on average, respondents tend to think of immigrant origins in racial terms but substantial variation in these perceptions exists. According to my correlational analyses, individual differences in racialized images of immigrant origin groups are associated with group-specific prejudice, attitudes toward immigration, and partisan affect. In Chapter IV, I propose a procedure to estimate multidimensional individual-level schemas as respondent-specific marginal component effects from conjoint experiments. The proposed strategy does not require any additional assumptions compared to the standard conjoint analysis, although some changes to the task design are recommended. Using this method, I find that schemas about immigration in the United States are dominated by immigrants’ race/ethnicity. Also, I present results from a priming experiment that suggest causal primacy of schemas with respect to attitudes. Overall, my dissertation makes several important contributions to political psychology and public opinion by exploring previously unmeasured variance in natives’ schemas about immigrants. To measure these schemas, I develop novel measurement techniques. With these measures, I demonstrate that schemas about “who the immigrants are” vary within the U.S. and British publics and that this variation is politically consequential. My results also indicate that immigrants’ race/ethnicity can be more important for immigration policy preferences than some recent studies suggest.
Author: Kirill Zhirkov
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3105907645
