Leader Behavior in Performance Appraisal Conversations: The Fostering of Psychological Safety in Subordinates
Year: 2020
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Purpose: The purpose of this study is to shed light on the leader-subordinate\ninteraction as it unfolds during the performance appraisal conversation. More\nspecifically, the aim is to look into how Model Ⅱ behavior in the leaders may\ncontribute to psychological safety in the subordinates. By doing this, we answer\nthe call of more qualitative studies in this field, which is needed in order to\nbridge the gap between scholars and practitioners.\nResearch Methodology: The study was conducted by recording the\nperformance appraisals of five leader-subordinate dyads in an organization, and\nby handing out a survey to the parties in the dyad afterwards. The performance\nappraisals were transcribed and coded based on a codebook partially developed\nby Meyer and colleagues (2019). The coded findings were then compared to\nanswers from the survey. Additionally, patterns found within the performance\nappraisal conversation were highlighted.\nFindings: Our findings suggest that leaders managed to maintain the\nrelationship with the subordinate, but especially due to a lack of inquiry, the\nsubordinate’s voice remained limited. The result is an ineffective PA,\nsuppressed psychological safety, and limited learning opportunities for both\nparties. Further, our findings propose that the overuse of active-empathetic\nlistening behavior such as humming can be counterproductive.\nImplications: Our overall findings suggest keeping the traditional performance\nappraisal, but with some alterations and leadership development in order to\nmake it more effective. Further, our findings arguably reflect the importance of\nthe leader’s behavioral nuances in relation to psychological safety in the\nperformance appraisal. This notion directs future research into also looking at\nauthentic behavior, and not only subordinates’ perceptions in surveys, when\nstudying the performance appraisal, not.
Source: NVA (Nasjonalt vitenarkiv)
Institution: BI Norwegian Business School
Language: English
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3107009124
