Work

The Case Study as Research Method: A Practical Handbook

Year: 2010
Type: book
Abstract: XIbottom line is that a guide must be a means not only of ensuring a priori but also of verifying a posteriori the rigorousness of the research process and providing assurance that the fi ndings are accurate.The purpose of this handbook is, precisely, to give researchers a tool to help them make an informed decision on whether the case method is appropriate and, if it is, to provide them with a guide to help them conduct the study with the required degree of rigour.The handbook covers the appropriateness and usefulness of the case study method, ways of ensuring accuracy of results, the required preparatory work, case selection, data collection, data analysis, and dissemination of results.The objective of each of the above stages is outlined, along with the main steps to be carried out.As one would expect, this handbook is full of practical examples with a focus on the various components of the research process rather than on the results.One particular example is used throughout the guide so that the reader can follow a specifi c case study from start to fi nish.It involves a research project that I carried out on the behaviour exhibited by executives of medium-sized businesses during the introduction of new technologies.I chose it because it formed the basis of my Ph.D. thesis and the work was closely and continuously supervised by a committee of three professors, one of whom was inclined towards the quantitative approach in his thinking and research activities.The principles and philosophy underpinning the quantitative approach were therefore a constant in my thesis project.The thesis itself is over 300 pages long and describes in detail every stage in the case study, the rationale behind it, the steps in it and the results achieved.An entire chapter is devoted to showing how, in practical terms, the reliability and validity of the data has been ensured.The results have been published in articles in two international journals (Gagnon and Toulouse 1993Toulouse , 1996)), which is to say the approach has been subject to further peer review and found to be sound.After completing my thesis, I decided to generalize my research results by applying a quantitative approach and, in particular, developing and administering a questionnaire.Once again, the results were reported in two scholarly publications (Gagnon 2001;Gagnon, Sicotte and Posada 2000).Many other examples are given to illustrate specifi c aspects of the case method.They show that the method is applicable to a broad range of fi elds in addition to management, the discipline from I N T R O D U C T I O N Human and social systems are complex.Understanding phenomena related to such systems demands a holistic approach, which can produce not only detailed descriptions of situations and events but also an in-depth understanding of the actors involved, their feelings and the interactions among them.Only qualitative research methods can provide a comprehensive view of this type (Benbasat, Goldstein and Mead 1983;Eisenhardt 1989;Patton 1982;Worthman and Roberts 1982).A case study, in particular, makes it possible to observe and analyze phenomena as a single, integrated whole (Bullock 1986).Quantitative methods, though useful, cannot do so, for their main tool, the questionnaire, is STEP OBJECTIVE 18. Select cases with characteristics that meet the initial research objectives.Observe phenomena relevant to the constructs of interest. STEP OBJECTIVE1. Purge the collected data.Make sure the data is relevant, in an appropriate format, and that the source and data collection method are known.2. Code the collected data on each case.Organize and sort the data to facilitate analysis.3. Analyze the coded data.Make the data speak by uncovering patterns.4. Write a description of each case.Organize the information that supports the patterns found in the analysis into a narrative.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3107417292
FWCI: 2.061
Cites: 76
Cited by: 116
Related to: 10