Decisions to adapt: trade-offs, maladaptation and transformations in Nordic agri-food systems
Year: 2020
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This thesis is a study of climate change adaptation as a human adjustment process in the context of Northern European agriculture. It deals with the human decision-making entailing uncertainty, risks and opportunities brought about by climate change and climate policies. Agricultural production of food in Northern Europe is under pressure. There are constant changes in societal structures, such as policies and economic markets, as well as climatic stressors. The climate impacts pose direct risks to production, such as increasing floods and droughts, as well as indirect pressures through, for example, the global demand for arable lands. This constantly changing and complex socio-environmental context of food production is expected to drive processes of adjustment in the agricultural sector. Recent assessments suggest that in most parts of Europe adaptation measures in the agricultural sector will increase significantly in the coming years. Agricultural adaptation research is focused on the climate risks with respect to production and on the development of technical solutions. Agricultural and food production sciences are at the front line of technical development of adaptation measures, such as new plant varieties, production environments and cultivation measures. There is also a growing body of literature on the systemic complexity of adaptation needs and options focused on climate impacts. Farm-scale adaptation is mainly studied in the development and management research fields among other applied research focused on developing countries, farm economics and local case studies. The current literature suggests that farmers will implement the adaptation measures in order to secure their livelihoods and to sustain the productivity of agricultural soils and lands. The perspective of agri-food system practitioners, nevertheless, is less represented in adaptation literature. This is also true of research on the societal drivers and outcomes of adaptation. That said, there is research suggesting that although adaptation is aimed at decreasing risks and vulnerability, the farm-scale adaptation measures may have unintended harmful impacts to different actors and resources. These are identified in yet few empirical studies to involve economic losses at farm scale, local environmental damage and short-term productivity decreases. This presents a gap in the research that should provide background knowledge for governing the complex field of adaptation in agriculture and food production sectors. From the perspective of environmental and social sciences, the adaptation measures call for focused assessment in terms of their social drivers and socio-environmental outcomes in all regions globally. This thesis sets out to address this gap and increase understanding on adaptation measures as an issue of decision-making within complex socio-environmental contexts and trade-offs. This thesis applies a qualitative empirical study with an interdisciplinary epistemological stand and methodological approach that draws on agri-food system practitioner perceptions. The focus is on crop farmers and on farm-scale adaptation. Furthermore, attention is paid to other professionals of the sector who deal with various agri-food systems, development and management, and in governance. The research starts with an analysis of adaptation measures and the drivers for their implementation at farm scale and the agricultural sector, followed by an analysis of the potential unintended harmful outcomes of these measures. Finally, the transformative adaptation measures that concern the food systems in the Nordic context are analysed. Key findings of this thesis show that climate change adaptation measures in the Nordic agri-food systems are currently aimed at reducing risks and increasing long-term adaptive capacity when it serves the highly contextual and often subjective needs. These do not always reflect the public policy goals and often involve harmful outcomes with respect to other actors and the sustainable development goals. To advance sustainable implementation of adaptation measures in Nordic agriculture inevitably requires governance interventions that include actors from various fields of society.
Source: Työväentutkimus Vuosikirja
Author: Janina Käyhkö
Language: English
Subfield: Agronomy and Crop Science
Domain: Life Sciences
SDGs: Zero hunger, Climate action
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3112784051
