The Experience of Implementing a Reablement Program for People Living with Dementia Across Different Health Contexts
Year: 2020
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Background: The Royal Commission into Aged Care Quality and Safety has found significant failures in our health system which has contributed to a lack of access and quality of care for people living with dementia. People living with dementia and their carers are calling out for access to interventions that address function; specifically, to increase independence and community engagement. Dyadic psychosocial interventions, namely reablement interventions, have been found to have a significant effect in reducing functional decline and increasing quality of life for people living with dementia. Reablement interventions have a strong evidence-base, are recommended in clinical practice guidelines and fit restorative care funding models, yet they mostly remain inaccessible for people in the community. Supporting the uptake of these effective programs through implementation research is imperative to overcoming barriers and facilitating this shift in practice. Organisational contexts influence the implementation of evidence-based programs and need to be considered when supporting organisations with uptake and sustainability. The systematic review presented in this thesis highlights that globally only eight reablement programs have been implemented, none so far in Australia. The Care of People with Dementia in their Environment (COPE) is one such program that has been proven to be effective; this thesis explores the experience of its implementation into the Australian health care system. \nObjectives: This thesis examines the perceptions of occupational therapists, nurses and their managers in the implementation of an evidence-based community program for people with dementia and their carers: COPE program within different organisational and health contexts in the Australian health and aged care system. \nMethods: Qualitative interpretive description formed the methodology alongside the epistemological standpoint of this work. In-depth interviews were collected from occupational therapists, nurses and their managers. Stratified purposeful sampling was conducted to ensure a variety of different organisational contexts were included. Interview data were analysed using thematic analysis. This thesis uses a novel analysis of schematic organisational diagrams was used to understand relationships within organisations and their influence on implementation.Results: A total of 57 in-depth interviews were conducted at two stages: during the preparation phase (n = 29) and after the occupational therapists and nurses had the opportunity to implement the intervention (n = 28). The major themes that influenced implementation were fitting within the organisation and alignment with the therapists’ commitment and intrinsic motivations. When the organisational values aligned and there was strong internal support, there was more proactive planning and problem solving when barriers arose (i.e. gaining referrals, matching with usual service provision and staff retention). The need to consider and strengthen health professionals’ relationships within the organisation, as well as develop marketing skills, were prominent features of the implementation experience. \nImplications: This theoretically informative empirical research contributes to health policy, organisational change, occupational therapy practice and implementation science through the in-depth discussion focused on pragmatic learnings, implications and recommendations. Knowledge generated through this study can provide guidance for organisations in planning for implementation of evidence-based programs and practice change. Implementing evidence-based programs required a significant shift in practice for therapists. Implementation was more successful when organisations engaged in proactive effort to develop systems and processes around implementation. Interdisciplinary relationships should be developed and/or strengthened with an aim to facilitate communication in order to work more collaboratively on shared priorities. A greater focus on unique core skills of occupational therapists over the more limited expectation of context driven tasks (such as equipment prescription or home medication) is imperative to practice change. Additionally, reframing the notion of ‘selling’ to that of empowerment, as well as focusing on developing relationships with the clinicians who will make referrals, are strategies to harness our occupational therapy skills for the purposes of promotion of new programs. For health policy, clear and separate funding models to increase access to reablement programs for people living with dementia and their carers. This thesis contributes to the ongoing advancement of empirical evidence in implementation science to continue alongside ongoing development of theory which ensures utility in real practice.
Author: Jennifer Culph
Institution: The University of Sydney
Language: English
Subfield: General Health Professions
Field: Health Professions
Domain: Health Sciences
Keywords: dementia, implementation barriers and facilitators, organizational context, occupational therapists, nurses, caregivers, community-based care, restorative care, organizational values, employee retention, referral, Royal Commission into Aged Care Quality and Safety, employee motivation, organizational relationships
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3118181981
