Work

COVID-19: Rapid antigen detection for SARS-CoV-2 by lateral flow assay: A national systematic evaluation of sensitivity and specificity for mass-testing

Year: 2021
Type: article
Abstract: BACKGROUND: Lateral flow device (LFD) viral antigen immunoassays have been developed around the world as diagnostic tests for SARS-CoV-2 infection. They have been proposed to deliver an infrastructure-light, cost-economical solution giving results within half an hour. METHODS: LFDs were initially reviewed by a Department of Health and Social Care team, part of the UK government, from which 64 were selected for further evaluation from 1st August to 15th December 2020. Standardised laboratory evaluations, and for those that met the published criteria, field testing in the Falcon-C19 research study and UK pilots were performed (UK COVID-19 testing centres, hospital, schools, armed forces). FINDINGS: 4/64 LFDs so far have desirable performance characteristics (orient Gene, Deepblue, Abbott and Innova SARS-CoV-2 Antigen Rapid Qualitative Test). All these LFDs have a viral antigen detection of >90% at 100,000 RNA copies/ml. 8951 Innova LFD tests were performed with a kit failure rate of 5.6% (502/8951, 95% CI: 5.1-6.1), false positive rate of 0.32% (22/6954, 95% CI: 0.20-0.48). Viral antigen detection/sensitivity across the sampling cohort when performed by laboratory scientists was 78.8% (156/198, 95% CI 72.4-84.3). INTERPRETATION: Our results suggest LFDs have promising performance characteristics for mass population testing and can be used to identify infectious positive individuals. The Innova LFD shows good viral antigen detection/sensitivity with excellent specificity, although kit failure rates and the impact of training are potential issues. These results support the expanded evaluation of LFDs, and assessment of greater access to testing on COVID-19 transmission. FUNDING: Department of Health and Social Care. University of Oxford. Public Health England Porton Down, Manchester University NHS Foundation Trust, National Institute of Health Research.
Authors: Tim Peto, Dominic Affron, Babak Afrough, Anita Agasu, Mark Ainsworth, Alison Allanson, Katherine Allen, Collette Allen, Lorraine Archer, Natasha Ashbridge, Iman Aurfan, Miriam Avery, Ellena Badenoch, Priya Bagga, Rishab Balaji, Ella Baldwin, Sophie Barraclough, Carol Beane, John Bell, Tracy Benford, Susan Bird, Marina Bishop, Angela Bloss, Richard Body, Rosie Boulton, Abbie Bown, Carla Bratten, Chris Bridgeman, Dominic Britton, Tim Brooks, Margaret Broughton-Smith, Pauline Brown, Beverley Buck, Elaine Butcher, Wendy Byrne, Gloria Calderon, Siobhan Campbell, Olivia Carr, Penny Carter, Daniel Carter, Megan Cathrall, Matthew Catton, Jim Chadwick, David Chapman, Kevin K. Chau, Tanzina Chaudary, Shaolin Chidavaenzi, Samatha Chilcott, Bea Choi, Hannah Claasen, Simon Clark, Richard Clarke, Dawn Clarke, Richard Clayton, Kayleigh Collins, Rima Colston, James Connolly, Eloïse Cook, Marie Corcoran, Ben Corley, Laura Costello, Caroline Coulson, Ant Crook, Derrick W. Crook, Silvia D'Arcangelo, Mary-Anne Darby, John Davis, Rosaline de Koning, Pauline Derbyshire, Pam Devall, Mark Dolman, Natalie Draper, Mark Driver, Sarah Dyas, Emily Eaton, Joy Edwards, Ruth Elderfield, Kate Ellis, Graham Ellis, Sue Elwell, Rachel Evans, Becky Evans, Marion Evans, Ranoromanana Evans, David Eyre, Codie Fahey, Vanessa Fenech, Janet Field, Alice Field, Tom Foord, Tom Fowler, Mollie French, Hannah Fuchs, Jasmine Gan, Joseph Gernon, Geeta Ghadiali, Narindar Ghuman, Kerry Gibbons, Gurvinder Gill, Kate Gilmour, Anika Goel, Sally Gordon, Tillie Graham, Alexander Grassam-Rowe, David Green, Anna Gronert, Tegan Gumsley-Read, Claire Hall, Bassam Hallis, Sally Hammond, Peter Hammond, Beth Hanney, Victoria Hardy, Gabriella Harker, Andrew Harris, May Havinden-Williams, Elena Hazell, Joanne Henry, Kim Hicklin, Kelly Hollier, Ben Holloway, Sarah J. Hoosdally, Susan Hopkins, Lucy Hughes, Steve Hurdowar, Sally-Anne Hurford, Joanne Jackman, Harriet Jackson, Ruth Johns, Susan Johnston, Juliet Jones, Tinashe Kanyowa, Katie Keating-Fedders, Sharon Kempson, Iftikhar Khan, Beinn Khulusi, Thomas Knight, Anuradha Krishna, Patrick Lahert, Zoe Lampshire, Daniel Lasserson, Kirsten Lee, Lennard Y.W. Lee, Arabella Legard, Cristina Leggio, Justin Liu, Teresa Lockett, Christopher Logue, Vanessa Lucas, Sheila F. Lumley, Vindhya Maripuri, Des Markham, Emma Marshall, Philippa C. Matthews, Sarah Mckee, Deborah F. McKee, Neil McLeod, Antoinette McNulty, Freddie Mellor, Rachel Michel, Alex Mighiu, Julie Miller, Zarina Mirza, Heena Mistry, Jane Mitchell, Mika Erik Moeser, Sophie Moore, Akhila Muthuswamy, Daniel Myers, Gemma Nanson, Mike Newbury, Scott Nicol, Harry Nuttall, Jewel Jones Nwanaforo, Louise Oliver, Wendy Osbourne, Jake Osbourne, Ashley Otter, Jodie Owen, Sulaksan Panchalingam, Dimitris Papoulidis, Juan Dobaldo Pavon, Arro Peace, Karen Pearson, Liam Peck, Ashley Pegg, Suzannah Pegler, Helen Permain, Prem Perumal, Leon Peto, Tim E.A. Peto, Thanh Pham, Hayleah L. Pickford, Mark Pinkerton, Michelle Platton, Ashley Price, Emily Protheroe, Hellen Purnell, Lottie Rawden, Sara Read, Charles Reynard, Susan Ridge, Tom G. Ritter, James Robinson, Patrick Robinson, Gillian Rodger, Cathy Rowe, Bertie Rowell, Alexandra Rowlands, Sarah Sampson, Kathryn Saunders, Rachel Sayers, Jackie Sears, Richard Sedgewick, Laura Seeney, Amanda Selassie, Lloyd Shail, Jane Shallcross, Lucy Sheppard, Anna Sherkat, Shelha Siddiqui, Alex Sienkiewicz, Lavanya Sinha, Jennifer Smith, Ella Smith, Emma Stanton, Thomas Starkey, Aleksander Stawiarski, Amelia Sterry, Joe Stevens, Mark Stockbridge, Nicole Stoesser, Anila Sukumaran, Angela Sweed, Sami Tatar, Hema Thomas, Carly Tibbins, Sian Tiley, Julie Timmins, Cara Tomas-Smith, Oliver Topping, Elena Turek, Toi Neibler, Kate Trigg-Hogarth, Elizabeth Truelove, Chris Turnbull, David Tyrrell, Alison Vaughan, John Vertannes, Richard Vipond, Linda Wagstaff, Joanne Waldron, Philip Walker, Ann Sarah Walker, Mary Walters, Jenny Y Wang, Ellie Watson, Kate Webberley, Kimerbley Webster, Grace Westland, Ian Wickens, Jane Willcocks, Herika Willis, Stephen Wilson, Barbara Wilson, Louise Woodhead, Deborah Wright, Bindhu Xavier, Fiona Yelnoorkar, Lisa Zeidan, Rangeni Zinyama
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $3,500
OpenAlex ID: W3168785831
FWCI: 17.51
Cites: 36
Cited by: 253
Related to: 9