Work

In the Scheme of Things: Sustainability as Seen Through the Lens of Salmon Aquaculture Sustainability Standards

Year: 2020
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This thesis was written as part of the SustainFish project, which was funded by the Norwegian Research Council (project number 254841). It explores the consequences of employing a technical understanding of certification and seeing sustainability as a technical outcome, in order to increase knowledge on how the aquaculture industry is, and should be, regulated. Specifically, this study maps the content of eight of the major sustainability standards for salmon aquaculture in Norway, Chile, and Scotland, generating a database with over 1900 sustainability indicators. Furthermore, it investigates the experiences of salmon aquaculture producers and auditors, providing insight into the actual workings of sustainability certification. Through document analysis, interviews, and fieldwork, this thesis examines the impression of sustainability that is created through the choice of content in these standards, the implementation of the standards, the impact of them, and the reciprocal influence between the “phases” (the 3 I’s) of the certification process. The findings are presented in five scientific papers.\nThe main contributions can be summarized as follows:\n•\tThe Wheel of Sustainability (WOS), a reference model for sustainable salmon aquaculture. In addition to being an important methodological contribution, this model serves as 1) a valid lexicon for the many issues related to improving the industry, 2) a tool for comparison of different improvement initiatives, and 3) a collaboration tool for identifying and addressing tradeoffs and other topics for consideration.\n•\t In-depth understanding of how certification schemes concretize “sustainabitlity” through the indicators they choose to include (and exclude), and how the concept is further operationalized through the implementation of these indicators. This involves a comprehensive mapping of the indicators in some of the major sustainability standards (resulting in a database of over 1900 indicators), and investigation of how salmon aquaculture companies strive to comply with these indicators.\n•\tIncreased knowledge about how standard indicators are received, perceived, and achieved differently across different companies and sites. This speaks to the challenges of governing at a distance, as there is often a great range between “standard” and “reality” - between global ideals and local realities.\n•\t Improved comprehension of what the behavioral dimension of certification effectiveness includes, through the development of specific content for the concept. The identified facilitators for behavioral change provide opportunities 1) for certification schemes to incorporate criteria that can better facilitate actual changes, 2) for salmon aquaculture companies to find ways in which to best achieve significant changes, and 3) for auditors to develop specific ways in which to assess companies on this dimension.\n•\tInsight into some of the key challenges and implications of governing through standardized indicators. These findings contribute to an acknowledgement of the inherent limitations of “governing at a distance” when employing a technical approach, as well as a proposal for a way forward.\n•\tSuggestions on how to better utilize the potential that sustainability certification has for improving the industry. This primarily involves refocusing efforts towards continuous improvement, flexibility, and facilitation of learning and knowledge building through interaction between the governing system and the objects to-begoverned.\n\n•\tBased on the findings of the study, this thesis advances a fundamental change in how certification and indicators as governmental technologies are understood and utilized. \n\nThis involves moving towards a recognition of “sustainability” as a processual construction, with emphasis on relative rather than absolute improvement. Building on this, the primary theoretical contribution of this thesis is the advocacy for a shift from a technical to a social understanding of certification, which stresses the role of flexibility, negotiation, and reciprocal knowledge production in applying these tools. This shift entails treating certification as a continuous governance process, by both acknowledging and utilizing the reciprocal influence between the different “phases” (the 3 I’s ) of the certification process.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3122397624
Cites: 275
Cited by: 3
Related to: 10