Work

The Power of Perspectives : Developing and Implementing Inter and Transdisciplinary Methods to Address Wicked Socio-Environmental Problems

Year: 2020
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Today, the wicked socio-ecological problems facing the world, like climate change and food security, are far too large-scale and complex for any single institution or academic discipline to address alone. Further, these often-contentious issues affect various stakeholders. Therefore, progress requires socially sensitive solutions that take all relevant parties' knowledge and values into account. Hence, participatory problem-solving approaches, like inter and transdisciplinary science, which invite diverse perspectives into the problem-solving process, are attractive options for combatting wicked problems. By integrating diverse knowledge bases and modes of thinking, these approaches can produce more creative, credible, democratically accountable, and socially acceptable solutions. However, despite the benefits they provide, these approaches must be developed further to ensure they reach their full potential. As such, chapters I and II of this thesis aim to promote the incremental advancement of inter and transdisciplinary science on two dimensions: First, chapter I aims to draw attention to the critical process of strengthening communication via cognitive integration. Cognitive integration "bridges the gaps" in understanding between members of diverse problem-solving teams, which eases communication and promotes collaborative work. Chapter I uses a paired structural topic modeling and interview analysis approach to identify and describe different perspectives about "risk," a key concept for the operational interdisciplinary team studied. Within this team, diverse perspectives about ideas as fundamental as the definition of risk and potential conflict areas were found, like the idea of quantitative risk analysis. Transparently revealing and describing the differences in perspectives within diverse teams in this way at the beginning of their collaborative work could help facilitate cognitive integration and direct conflict resolution efforts, thereby enabling inter and transdisciplinary teams to begin their work more smoothly and effectively. The second area for development this thesis aims to address is the lack of peer-reviewed methods in inter and transdisciplinary research. Specifically, chapter II describes the development of a new method for mental model elicitation, which is a popular tool within transdisciplinary research. Mental model elicitation is intended to document a participant's causal understanding of a problem system. However, the academic literature rarely discusses the elicitation process, and those approaches it does describe, direct and indirect elicitation, are likely to either oversimplify the participants' ideas or introduce facilitator bias, respectively. Chapter II describes the Rich Elicitation Approach (REA), which combines both approaches in a single framework to maintain the benefits of each while compensating for their shortcomings. Unlike chapters I and II, the final chapter of this thesis, chapter III, focuses on a real-world transdisciplinary problem-solving effort. Specifically, chapter III reports the outcomes of a problem framing study to understand how climate change may affect salmon and their fishery in the Baltic Sea region and direct fishery management accordingly. Chapter III makes use of the REA developed in chapter II, as stakeholders' mental models form the basis of this study. By analyzing these models, 15 themes describing the problem, goals for the salmon management considering climate change, and strategies to help achieve those goals were found. Additionally, chapter III identified potentially conflicting values and ideas that salmon management may need to address moving forward. Problem framing is only the first step toward addressing the climate change issue for salmon management. Continuing efforts will require the cooperation of diverse problem-solving teams in a contentious management context, which could be facilitated by transparently acknowledging and describing perspective differences, as was done in chapter I.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3123056581
Cites: 211
Cited by:
Related to: 9