The Adoption of Specialised Competition Tribunals in Latin American Countries: Lessons from Mexico
Year: 2020
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The adoption of specialised tribunals has become a widespread \nphenomenon notwithstanding the scarcity of empirical evidence about \ntheir real benefits. This thesis seeks to remedy such a gap by assessing \nthe performance of the recently adopted specialised competition tribunal \nin Mexico. The analysis of the performance of this tribunal focuses on the \nfeedback collected by the author in interviews with key stakeholders. In \nspecific terms, this assessment reveals the nature and magnitude of the \nissues that led to the adoption of this new tribunal and the institutional \nreform it entailed. \nIn broad terms, it offers the three following implications. First, it provides \nexperimental verification about the veracity of the three most common \nbenefits attributed to specialised tribunals: efficiency, quality, and \nuniformity. Second, it confirms that as different institutions take part in \nthe implementation of competition law, the performance of one \ninstitution influences another. In the event that the judiciary is unfamiliar \nwith competition law, unskilled in economics, inclined to dispose \nantitrust cases based on procedural irregularities and delays, the \nfunctioning of the competition agencies is obscured, and the effective \nimplementation of the competition law impeded. Third, it verifies the \nconnection between country specific socio-economic conditions and \nlevels of implementation of competition law. These implications derive \nfrom the analysis of the Mexican case and the commonalities shared \nbetween this country and some other Latin American countries. \nThe most important lesson to be learnt from the Mexican case is that the \nadoption of specialised competition tribunals is advisable to Latin \nAmerican countries facing similar challenges in the implementation of \ncompetition law. Yet the lessons offered by the Mexican case provide \nvital insights but need to be carefully adapted to ensure a suitable transfer \nto other jurisdictions. For this purpose, this thesis offers a conceptual \nframework about transplants, which applied in conjunction with their \ndomestic realities, predicts a successful replication. Finally, it offers \nrecommendations on what needs to be considered when adopting a \nspecialised competition tribunal.
Author: Claudia Lemus
Institution: Queen Mary University of London
Language: English
Subfield: Economics and Econometrics
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3123551783
