Work

Why Lead Labor? Projects and Pathways in California Unions, 1984-2001

Year: 2003
Type: preprint
Abstract: How We Learned about Union LeadershipThe initial data for this study comes from a set of interviews with 130 California union leaders conducted by Marshall Ganz and Scott Washburn in 1984 in an effort to assess the future direction of the California labor movement.With the support of California labor organizations and a number of small foundations, Ganz and Washburn targeted a set of younger full time union leaders, most of whom had organizing experience, who had also earned positions of responsibility in their unions and reputations among their colleagues for a commitment to union revitalization.The interviewees were broadly representative of the full range of California unions, industries, and regions, but special emphasis was placed on those who were 30-45 years of age at the time, particularly women, people of color, organizers, and those with records of success.Eighty-six people in the original sample were in this age range.The unions they worked for included those active in the public sector, services, manufacturing, the building trades and transportation.The 2-3 hour interviews were extensive and focused on the respondent's family background, career to date, mentoring, views of organizing, beliefs about leadership, and expectations for the future.Based on notes taken in the interviews, Ganz and Washburn completed protocols which they then coded.However, other than presentations made to union leaders in 1985-6, and references in a few articles (Kuttner 1987), the findings were never published.Instead, until 2001, the notes rested in a trunk in a Salinas warehouse.The present study builds on this data by re-interviewing the original respondents to compare their positions in 1984 with their positions now and learn how they got there.We learned of their successes and their failures, the opportunities they encountered, barriers they faced, and how they dealt with them.We paid particular attention to their "projects", how they have changed, and how this interacted with their career choices, organizational turning points, and leadership roles.Our first task was to locate the original cohort, a search that got underway in the spring of 2001.Once we found most of them, we conducted a set of 2-3 hour semistructured interviews, tape recorded them, transcribed the tapes, wrote up short "debriefs" after each interview, and met regularly as a research team of 5 to discuss and analyze them.We analyzed responses, developed categories, coded where appropriate, and evaluated quantitatively where possible.For this paper, we look only at the people in the original sample who were between 30 and 45 years of age when they were first interviewed in 1984.As Table 1 shows, 84 or 98% of these people were still living.We were able to contact 75 of them, or 87%.Of these, 48 or 64% were still working for unions, 3 had retired from a union, and 24 or 32%
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3123980704
Cites: 22
Cited by: 2
Related to: 10