Constructing "Climate Migration" as a Global Governance Issue: Essential Flaws in the Contemporary Literature
Year: 2013
Type: preprint
Abstract: 1. INTRODUCTION 2. THE PHENOMENON: UNDERSTANDING THE LINKS BETWEEN CLIMATE CHANGE AND MIGRATION 2.1. Observing Inducement to 2.2. Conceptualizing Climate Migration 2.3. The Temptation of Conceptual Fragmentation 3. THE PROJECT: GOVERNING CLIMATE MIGRATION? 3.1. Governing What? 3.2. Inconsistent Rationales 3.3. Hints at a Constructivist Analysis 4. CONCLUSION PUBLICATIONS UNDER REVIEW MONOGRAPHS: * Jane McAdam, Change, Forced Migration, and International Law (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2011) (1) * Gregory White, Change and Migration: Security and Borders in a Warming World (New York: Oxford University Press, 2011) (2) EDITED VOLUMES: * Jane McAdam, ed, Change and Displacement: Multidisciplinary Perspectives (Oxford: Hart Publishing, 2010) (3) * Etienne Piguet, Antoine Pecoud & Paul de Guchteneire, eds, and Change (Cambridge: (Cambridge University Press, 2011) (4) PROJECT REPORTS: * Jill Jager et al, eds, Synthesis Report (14 May 2009), online: EACH-FOR Project * Foresight: and Global Environmental Change, Final Project Report (London: The Government Office for Science, 2011), online: Department of Business, Innovation & Skills . * Koko Warner et al, Where the Rain Falls: Global Policy Report (Care and United Nations University Institute for Environment and Human Security, 2012), online: United Nations University . The link between change and migration is no longer under-studied. At least a dozen books and reports were published on this topic between 2009 and 2012 revealing that many people were or would be migrating because of environmental changes, particularly changes linked to change, and calling for the development of appropriate international responses. (5) Despite this abundance of literature, however, a frequent claim is that more research is needed. (6) The debate on migration has therefore entered a self-justifying expansion, where a growing body of uncritical research leads to the constant call for further research. (7) The present essay will underscore some of the tensions and contradictions in contemporary multidisciplinary literature on migration, explaining the constant dissatisfaction of researchers with their own results. The underlying argument is that more research is not needed, but rather better research is needed. Researchers should focus their work on answering the right questions, not on simply answering more questions. A critical perspective is urgently needed in migration research. Certainly, contradictions are frequent and understandable in any new field of research. New concepts and terminology need to be adopted and agreed upon. Here, this is no easy feat, as there are unsurprisingly different ways of conceiving or describing the causal relationship between change and migration. Broadly speaking, this essay will show that that the governance debate on migration suffers from insufficient attention to multidisciplinary studies. Despite frequent sensational stories about climate refugees by the media, the phenomena at issue in the debate on environmental migration are not as simple as they may seem. For a long time, strongly different views distinguished the maximalist or researchers from the minimalist or sceptical ones. As Francois Gemenne describes, The alarmist perspective, often championed by environmental scholars, the media and civil society, claims that environmental disruptions, among which the impacts of change in particular, will induce massive population displacements. …
Source: SSRN Electronic Journal
Author: Benoît Mayer
Institution: Chinese University of Hong Kong
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3125799391
