Work

Gatekeeping and General Practice in the Australian Health System

Year: 2020
Type: dissertation
Abstract: General practice is central to primary care in the Australian health system, yet difficulties proving the value of general practice are ongoing. Advocates of general practice often refer to a key role general practitioners (GPs) play in health system gatekeeping to emphasise the importance of general practice within the system. However, the concept of gatekeeping lacks clarity, and this may lead to unintended consequences for general practice. \nThis thesis explores the concept of gatekeeping within the Australian health system by considering the expectations of general practice held by policymakers, advocacy groups and general practitioners concerning general practice as the controller of economic value in health care. The study analysed media releases from policymakers and advocacy groups and conducted interviews with 19 GPs. Using a methodology which attempts to reflect a general practice approach to problem solving, the study considered the discourse of policymakers, GPs and advocacy groups concerning waste within the system, to determine attitudes towards gatekeeping. \nThe study found that policymakers, influenced by neoliberal ideas, equate good health with good economics and have an expectation that GPs will consider cost when making clinical decisions. GPs, while thoughtful of cost, prioritise patient well-being in treatment. Policymaker and GP expectations of care are opposed. While gatekeeping has appeal in a neoliberal environment, failure to meet economic expectations exposes GPs to accusations of poor practice. Advocacy for general practice should recognise the value of general practice in the Australian health system extends beyond reductionist financial expectations and re-centring policy discourse on health outcomes rather than economic outcomes is likely to have most success in improving the status of general practice within the system.
Language: English
Subfield: Family Practice
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3134931820
Cites: 298
Cited by: 6
Related to: 10