Year: 2018
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Ethics is an integral part of clinical research involving human subjects as research participants.Clinical research is an increasingly collaborative action enabling ethical research.However, little attention has been paid to ethical aspects of the clinical research conducted in the hospitals.This study was carried out to describe ethically conducted clinical research in hospitals from the perspective of nurse leaders and administrative staff including principal investigators, administrative managers, and elected officials and via a synthesis of previous studies.The study comprised three sub-studies.The first was a two-phase qualitative one focusing on the ethical aspects of clinical research from the standpoint of nurse leaders (n=10) and administrative staff (n=31).This sub-study was conducted in two phases.Data were collected via semi-structured face-to-face interviews, firstly with nurse leaders in autumn 2012 and then with administrative staff in summer-autumn 2014.Both phases utilised inductive content analysis.Sub-study two involved secondary supra-analysis of the pre-existing interview data (n=41).This was focused on collaborative partnership and social value of clinical research, and other ethical requirements presented in the Ethical Framework for Clinical Research (Emanuel et al., 2000, 2004;Emanuel and Wendler, 2008).The data analysis took the form of deductive-inductive content analysis aided by NVivo software.The third sub-study was an integrative literature review focusing on the topical aspects of privacy in clinical research.From PubMed, CINAHL and Scopus database searches, empirical and theoretical papers (n=16) published in 2012-2017 were subjected to the constant comparison analysis method (Whittemore and Knafls, 2005).Nurse leaders and administrative staff considered human subjects' autonomy a central yet threatened ethical principle in clinical research practice at hospitals.In addition, collaborative partnership was identified as a cornerstone for ethical clinical research.Ways to foster collaboration among stakeholders, such as supporting mutual respect and equality, shared goals, and clearly defined roles and responsibilities, emerged also.While the social value of clinical research was considered an important precondition for ethical clinical research and the multidimensional social value of clinical research was described, the results indicate also that this multidimensional value remained partly unidentified in society.Achieving greater social value for clinical research was found to require greater transparency, setting of research priorities, shared responsibility for the dissemination and use of the findings, and stronger community awareness of the ethical aspects of clinical research.Moreover, an integrative literature review identified that human subjects' privacy is increasingly related to topical ethical aspects of clinical research in light of changing research practice.Six topical aspects were identified: the evolving nature of health data in clinical research, sharing of health data, the challenges of anonymising data, collaboration among stakeholders, complexity of regulation, and ethics-related tension between social benefits and privacy.Perspectives of nurse leaders and administrative staff were shown to form an essential element for understanding the multifaceted picture of ethically conducted clinical research in hospitals.Accordingly, their views should be considered in the planning and implementation of clinical research in hospitals, in order to ensure ethically conducted research.
Author: Sanna‐Maria Nurmi
Institution: University of Eastern Finland
Language: English
Topic: Ethics in Clinical Research
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3136720156
