Morphologic patterns of diversification: examples from trilobites
Year: 1991
Type: article
Abstract: The morphologic diversification of the Trilobita is investigated using a Fourier description of the cramdia of Cambrian and Ordovician trilobites from North America.Morphologic diversity increases from the Early Cambrian to the Middle Ordovician, but does not correlate well with patterns of generic or familial diversity.Suprageneric taxa of trilobites are shown objectively to represent morphotypes.Morphologic dispersion among suprageneric taxa and the distinctness of these taxa both increase from the Cambrian to the Ordovician.This result agrees with patterns based on hypostomal morphology (Whittington 1988a, 19886), and therefore is not an artifact of using cranidial morphology.These patterns are caused by the origination of new higher taxa, not evolution within established higher taxa.Higher taxa tend to retain the same morphology once established, rather than diverging gradually.In this respect, higher taxa may be said to have sudden origins.The origination of higher taxa may be linked to the opening of new adaptive zones, particularly in the Early Ordovician, following widespread extinctions of trilobites.The fossil record clearly indicates that evolutionary change is not evenly distributed over time, but is concentrated in episodes of evolutionary radiation.For the Metazoa at least, the early Phanerozoic represents the most important of these episodes.Yet, despite its significance, a limited number of approaches has been used to study this great diversification, most notably the analysis of taxonomic data (e.g.Valentine 1969;Erwin et al. 1987).Often implicit in the analysis of diversification by 'taxon counting' is the assumption either that morphologic diversity can be measured by taxonomic diversity, or that the number of taxa reflects the number of objectively discernible morphotypes.Valentine (1969), for example, used the assumption that the separation among groups at a higher taxonomic level usually represents a larger morphological divergence than that among groups at a lower level in order to draw conclusions about community evolution from temporal patterns in the appearance of groups at various taxonomic levels.Although we know that taxonomic data and morphologic data often correlate, taxonomic and morphologic approaches are not simply redundant.If taxa are consistently defined, then taxonomic data can tell us about the number of biological units at a given time.But if we want to know the nature of these units, how they originate, and how they evolve once established, morphologic data are clearly necessary.Since form represents the raw data of palaeobiology, it is important to document significant events in the history of life from the standpoint of morphology.Because the events of the early Phanerozoic diversification are concentrated in the Cambrian and Ordovician, documenting patterns of morphologic evolution associated with this radiation requires a well preserved fossil group that is diverse and abundant during these two periods.Trilobites are clearly the group of choice.Although all skeletonized metazoan phyla were present by the Ordovician, some 75 % of known Cambrian species were trilobites, while trilobites account for 23 % of described Ordovician species (Raup 1976).It is the availability of trilobites, rather than any intrinsic property such as complexity, that makes them useful for a case study in diversification.This study has two principal objectives: (1) to document patterns of morphologic diversification in the Trilobita during the Cambrian and Ordovician; and (2) to investigate morphologic dispersion within and among suprageneric taxa of trilobites in order to determine the taxonomic level(s) at which morphologic diversification is concentrated.Although this paper focuses on trilobites, it is important to keep in mind that trilobites provide only a case study.It is hoped that the results may yield generalizations regarding morphologic radiation when compared to information from other
Author: Foote, Mike
Language: English
Subfield: Paleontology
Field: Earth and Planetary Sciences
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3137053471
