Differenzierung von Gewaltverbrechen unter der Berücksichtigung der Alkohol-Klassifikation nach Lesch
Year: 2010
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: The Lesch classification of alcohol addiction is a modern instrument comprising a typology and parameters of personal history, prognosis, and therapy. Aim of this work was the application of these parameters to a group of alcohol addicts who had been sentenced for violent crime. Alcoholism-relevant data were drawn from psychiatric reports to group patients according to the Lesch classification. The cohort of 38 patients was predominantly males with a mean age of 38 years. To allow a systematic analysis, a problem-oriented data sheet was generated. Grouping of the delinquents according to Lesch resulted in a highly imbalanced distribution: 60% were type I, 16% type II, 21% type III, and 3% type IV: Around half of the committed crimes for all types were intended homicide, followed by murder, intended murder and, least frequent, homicide. Blood alcohol levels of Lesch type I and II at the time of crime ranged between 1.5 to 2.5 per mil, of type III and IV delinquents between 0 and 1.5 per mil. Categorizing the criminal tools as A, “criminal tools per se (i.e., weapons)” and B, “daily items (mis)used as criminal tools”, the type I delinquent was violent with an A tool in 13 and with a B tool in 10 instances. Type II delinquents took an A tool in 4 and a B tool in 2 instances while type III offenders used 2 times an A tool and 6 times a B tool. The single type IV person took an A. Almost all delinquents were judged on the basis of § 21 while § 20 was never applied. Data analysis yielded prototypical offender profiles, which, regarding the small numbers per type are verbalized for type I only: The type I delinquent is scoring low on a suicidal scale and is a knifer convicted of intended homicide. He is typically striking while being moderately alcoholized in the first 6 months of the year, between 6 pm and midnight, at home or in the road. The open question against the background of this data set is whether the frequency of homicidal acts or attempts is Lesch-type-inherent or whether type I alcoholics (being the most frequent type in normal life cohorts) are relatively non-violent due their high alcohol tolerance, their adapted drinking and/ or their relatively developed social competence. The criminal profiles of the other Lesch types and their intrinsic violence potential remain vague due to small numbers. It may perhaps be disillusioning to note that the majority of the persons in this study used A tools for their violent offence and only type III alcoholics seem to not have the latent inclination to carry (and make use of) an A weapon. Since, per definition, type I alcoholics do not bear a psychiatric stigma other than alcohol addiction, they can be pleaded guilty in case of delinquency all the more if by carrying an offensive weapon they aim at structuring and dominating their social field. The effect of alcohol might also increase the offensive potential in type I alcoholics. However, the considerable frequency of “failed” homicide in this group of delinquents argues for residual self control in these persons in critical situations.
Author: Babett Ute Lindner
Institution: Friedrich-Alexander-Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg
Language: German
Subfield: Clinical Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3139436823
