Work

Into the silence : a critical narrative of student choice, experience and identity at a private career college in Northern Ontario

Year: 2018
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This study explores why six students chose to attend a private career college (PCC) in northern Ontario, and how stories of their experiences and choices impact their identities. In doing so, the study addresses the research problem that despite growing numbers of PCC enrollments in Ontario, PCCs remain under researched (Li & Jones, 2015; Pizarro Milian & Hicks, 2014), and what little research exists excludes the student voice almost in its entirety. The result is that very little is known about how PCC students experience their education, or about what other benefits there may be in addition to the labour-related ones that dominate approaches to PCC research and government data collection. This is particularly problematic in light of demographics that demonstrate that Ontario PCCs serve higher percentages of students who are marginalized and/or underrepresented in postsecondary education than its public counterparts (Malatest & Associates, 2008; Martin & MacLaine, 2016; Pizarro Milian, & Hicks, 2014). The study contributes to this research gap with a critical narrative inquiry conducted through a series of three semi-structured interviews with each participant over seven months. Critical feminist theories guided data analysis towards the construction of participant narratives of their early school experiences and decisions to attend the PCC, and an exploration of the thematic threads across their experiences. The critical feminist framework was further used to interrogate how knowledge practices in schools impact PCC student choice, and to privilege the role of participants as co-constructors of meaning. Key findings include that PCC student choice is much more complex than existing research demonstrates; that PCC education can lead to surprising outcomes (such as increased self-confidence and transformative identity work) that are often overlooked by prevalent labour-related approaches to PCC research; and, that PCC students are impacted by the stigma that exists in Ontario towards PCCs as low quality education. Recommendations are made for PCCs and policy makers, such as encouraging the reevaluation of how PCC quality is measured in Ontario, particularly given recent pushes by the Ontario government to evaluate PCCs more stringently on labour-related criteria. The study demonstrates that labour-related approaches alone risk eclipsing other (intended and unintended) benefits of attending a PCC.
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3141615118
Cites: 122
Cited by:
Related to: 10