Work

A cross-cultural study of noncompliant behaviors in Japanese and United States hospitals : noncompliance as a response to perceived threats of shame, embarrassment, and management sanctions

Year: 1997
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: In the research reported here, comparable measures are created of the perceived threats of shame, embarrassment, and management sanctions for three categories of occupational deviant conduct (taking a long lunch or break without approval, coming to work late or leaving early without approval, and using sick leave when not really sick). The effects of three punishment threats on people's intention to violate three organizational rules are then examined in merged samples of employees in Japanese and U.S. university hospitals. Compared to American employees, Japanese employees perceive greater threats of shame, embarrassment, and management sanctions and, subsequently, are less likely to commit each of the three offenses. The lower likelihood of Japanese employees to take a long lunch or break without approval or use sick leave when not really sick is primarily attributable to their greater threat of shame. Despite their lower intention to commit the future offenses, the analyses indicate that all three sanction threats have less of a deterrent impact for Japanese employees than for American employees, and these findings for interaction effects are not consistent with the predictions of the current research.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3143864242
Cites: 79
Cited by: 3
Related to: 10