Work

Distant Neighbours: Social Distance, Mobility Prospects, and Government Redistribution

Year: 2020
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This dissertation is about income inequality – how it shapes preferences for redistribution, whether governments are responsive to these preferences, and whose preferences matter most. Income inequality has become a salient topic in recent decades, as the gap between rich and poor has widened across advanced industrial economies. Models of rational self-interest would predict that the increased concentration of income at the top of the distribution would increase public demand for government action to redress this inequality, yet public support for redistribution in many advanced economies has remained constant or even declined. At the same time, governments have often pursued greater redistribution in low rather than high market inequality settings. How can we understand these trends? This dissertation addresses this question by focusing on the Canadian provincial context, examining both demand for, and supply of, government redistribution. On the demand side, I argue that social distance – perceptions of similarity or difference among groups – affects how people think about their own economic prospects, in turn shaping their preferences for redistribution. Demand for redistribution depends not only on an individual’s position in the income distribution; instead, the distribution of income within neighbourhoods, among income groups, and across ethnic groups all influence preferences for government inequality reduction. On the supply slide, this dissertation also examines how micro-patterns of preferences and inequality are translated into government supply of redistribution, and in particular whether governments are more responsive to middle- or high-income groups. Despite concern in recent American politics research about the outsized influence of high-income voters on government policy, I show that provincial governments are responsive to the economic conditions of the middle class. However, high-income voters are often as – or more – responsive than middle-income voters to shifts in the income position of the middle class, suggesting that governments can respond to the middle class without opposition from higher-income voters. This dissertation contributes to our understanding of the relationship between group membership and redistributive preferences, the other-regarding versus self-interested bases of support for redistribution, and research on unequal government responsiveness to the public’s preferences.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3149864019
Cites: 156
Cited by:
Related to: 10