Work

Collective Belief and Scientific Change

Year: 2000
Type: preprint
Abstract: Scientific progress may be understood to involve a given scientific community’s changing its mind. This raises the question: what is it for such a change to occur? Is it, or is it solely, a matter of individual scientists changing their minds? This paper argues for an alternative conception in terms of a conception of collective belief that it explains. Given their internal structure, collective beliefs act as constraints on the actions and utterances of the members of a given scientific community, and it takes more than a change in individual minds to change them. This may help to explain the phenomenon of outsiders or neophytes who contribute to scientific progress, as in the case of the bacterial theory of ulcers.
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3154833530
Cites:
Cited by: 36
Related to: 10