Work

Understanding how groups make strategic decisions in emergencies

Year: 2020
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This thesis investigates how emergency response groups, specifically Strategic \nCoordinating Groups, make decisions in time-pressured, high-stakes environments. \nBy analysing video footage of simulated emergency exercises, the approach taken \ncombines the reproducibility of traditional decision-making studies with the realism \nadvocated by the paradigm of Naturalistic Decision Making. The investigation of \ndecision-making at a range of national and international exercises revealed \nsystematic departures from the UK doctrine on making group decisions: The Joint \nDecision Model. Group decision-making did not follow the sequence of activities \nassumed by the Joint Decision Model or other normative models of decision-making. \nThere were marked between-group differences in the process of decision-making: \nsome groups can be characterised as information seeking (or explorers), others as \naction orientated (or exploiters). When making decisions, all groups rarely \nconsidered alternative courses of action or options. This thesis provides \nrecommendations on the policy and practice of how Strategic Coordinating Groups \ntrain and exercise and make decisions in emergencies. These include a national \nprogramme of training for the Chairs of Strategic Coordination Groups, use of \ncontrols and tools to support decision-making, and use of external challenge and \nassessment in strategic decision-making.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3160510049
Cites: 121
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10