Work

What is Islamic Esotericism?

Year: 2019
Type: article
Abstract: The prominence of Corbin and the inclusion of Chittick and Nasr is indicative of an adherence to a "Westernist" attitude, since these authors represented in their works a form of universalism directed and influenced by Western Traditionalist and perennialist perspectives.5 This is explicit in Faivre's discussion of "imagination and mediation," the third out of four primary criteria of Western esotericism.Without delving into the oft-discussed problematics of his criteria, it is worth noting that Faivre references Henry Corbin's concept of mundus imaginalis, which he describes as "an Arabic influence (Avicenna, Sohravardi, Ibn Arabi) [that] was able to exert a determinative influence here in the West."6 The three mentioned here are the Muslim "sweethearts" of perennial philosophy.As will be later shown, this is a persistent reduction of Islamic esotericism.Furthermore, in a note on Corbin, Faivre writes, "In this area, H. Corbin is the principal reference author.Reading his works not only allows us into Shiite esotericism, but also helps us to better understand Judeo-Christian esotericism, especially since the author himself never missed the opportunity to establish discerning connections.All of his work should be cited."7 Despite the above-mentioned reductionism, credit must be given to Faivre's implicit invitation to look at Islamic esotericism as the other side of the story of Western esotericism, something that is often overlooked by his critics as we shall see below.Accepting Western esotericism as "a modern scholarly construct," without denying any reality to the field, 8 Wouter Hanegraaff echoes Faivre when he admits 5. Knysh, Sufism, 39; Ernst, "Traditionalism, the Perennial Philosophy, and Islamic Studies," 176-81; Sedgwick, Against the Modern World, 157.Corbin and Chittick did so in the context of Eranos (for its perennial commitment see Hakl, Eranos, 221, 254; Sedgwick, Western Sufism, 20-35; Sedgwick, Against the Modern World, 153-57.6. Faivre, Access to Western Esotericism, 12-13.7. Faivre, Access to Western Esotericism, 338.8. Hanegraaff, A Guide for the Perplexed, 3-4.
Author: Liana Saif
Language: English
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W3164182703
FWCI: 23.59
Cites: 51
Cited by: 37
Related to: 10