Parliamentary Sovereignty and Constitutional Futures
Year: 2019
Type: preprint
Abstract: In the face of growing scepticism about parliamentary sovereignty, this chapter considers the relationship between the doctrine and constitutional reform in the UK.
The first section draws on the work of Keith Ewing to examine the idea of parliamentary sovereignty as an instrument for democratic political change, but also identifies the limitations on the potential which is offered by parliamentary sovereignty as a constitutional norm. In particular, the chapter discusses, first, the lack of a defined constitutional future for the UK, and second, our complacency about the possibilities for reforming the constitution.
The second section then begins to explore what a radical constitutional future might look like in the UK. Or perhaps more accurately, it tries to sketch how a radical approach to UK constitutionalism might take shape, given the aim is not to delineate some particular ideal set of arrangements, but instead to open up discussion of the possibilities that could be considered.
The chapter argues that these are possibilities that ought to be seriously considered, if we are to make the potential of parliamentary sovereignty more than just an attractive idea, and show how it might actually be utilised in the real world constitution. In starting to sketch these possibilities, the second section explores the potential for substantive constitutional reform in the UK, but also the more complex question of the possibility of radicalism in terms of the form of the constitution itself.
In large parts, this paper is therefore obviously normative, contestable, and might seem removed from the practicalities of the day-to-day constitution. Yet this normativity is not intended to be an exercise in indulgent hypothesising, or constitutional wish-fulfilment. Instead, it serves a broader purpose: when the constitutional appeal of parliamentary sovereignty is based on its potential for change, we must understand the possibilities for the UK’s constitutional future if that potential is to be meaningful, let alone if it is ever to be realised.
Source: SSRN Electronic Journal
Author: Michael Gordon
Institution: University of Liverpool
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3168472260
