Book review: Water Politics: Governance, Justice, and the Right to Water edited by Farhana Sultana and Alex Loftus
Year: 2021
Type: book-review
Abstract: Water is essential to human and living beings both for its physical and non-physical forms that enable humans to function.This book broadens discussions about water, from its physical dimensions and its use to beyond-physical ontological forms of water.The authors show that water is situated as a crucial part of social, cultural, and spiritual beings.Departing from the ontological pluralism of water, water has become more contested, not only as a commodity that is inseparable from the well-functioning of human lives but also as part of the living ecosystem.This book, not only deepens such frames of analysis but also advances recent debates around water bodies/ rivers/ oceans as having a right in and of itself as part of the multispecies living being in a shared space of planet Earth.Further, this book contributes to re-centering water as a fundamental environmental justice issue.This book contributes to the debates around the recognition aspects of justice, which makes claims for acknowledgement of different sets of values and cultural practices underlying valuation of water, which are often dominated by materialistic values.As Linton suggests on page 63 'No amount of citizen participation, social learning or stakeholder involvement in decision making process is likely to resolve the problem of different waters realised through different practices… without recognition of different political ontologies."This book provides a structured means for not only responding to the political and social problems in realising the right to water, but also its meta-political representation (formation of its very framings) (Fraser, 2009), of which we are allowed to claim for justice.Water Politics: Governance, Justice and the Rights to Water asks "how far have we made progress in realising [the] right to water?And under what frames are these policies and practices operating?".This book discusses a broad range of topics from the politics of water and water governance, human rights to water, and engages with water through the capabilities framework, addressing key issues around the water-food security nexus, water justice, and the intersectionality of water in varied contexts of the Global South and Global North, bridging urban and rural areas.The book highlights the evolving political ontologies of and about water across temporal, spatial, and governing scales, and how interpretations of such plural conceptions have been realised so far.The editors compiled various papers highlighting the progress that has been made in delivering and claiming rights to water across geographical-spatial contexts in the past three decades.The authors adopt a critical geography approach to water, and each of the fourteen articles present deep observations and critical analysis of empirical cases.While Linton's contribution in particular, entitled 'The rights to bring waters into being', engaging in a more theoretical debate on contesting the dominant political ontology of water in a globalised capitalist society and its
Source: Forest and Society
Author: Naimah Talib
Institution: The University of Melbourne
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $300
OpenAlex ID: W3169161206
