Deterrence is Down and Social Costs are Up: A Parolee Revisits Pennsylvania Board of Probation and Parole v. Scott
Year: 2007
Type: preprint
Abstract: In Pennsylvania Board of Probation & Parole v. Scott, Justice Clarence Thomas, writing for the Court, held that the exclusionary rule does not extend to parole revocation hearings. Balancing the potential deterrent effect of the exclusionary rule on law enforcement violations of the Fourth Amendment against the social costs of preventing illegally seized evidence to be used at parole revocation hearings, the Court provided four tenuous justifications for its holding. These justifications are now outdated and obsolete. Subsequent decisions by the Court and current empirical data question the rationales put forth by Justice Thomas to support the conclusion that the exclusionary rule has no place in a parole revocation proceeding. This Essay examines the hypotheses employed in Pennsylvania Board of Probation & Parole v. Scott from the practical perspective of a parolee. Ignoring hypothetical deterrence and miscalculated social costs, while analyzing pertinent studies Justice Thomas failed to cite and exploring the actualities of supervised release, the rest of this Essay explains how the justifications of Scott do not apply to the parole system of today and how application of the exclusionary rule in parole revocation hearings where violations of the Fourth Amendment occur is one step toward fixing a system of supervision that is now in disrepair.
Source: SSRN Electronic Journal
Author: James M. Binnall
Institution: California State University, Long Beach
Language: English
Topic: Criminal Law and Evidence
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3181204440
