Work

Selecting appropriate cases when studying causal mechanisms

Year: 2014
Type: preprint
Abstract: This article games through the methodological consequences that adopting a systems understanding of causal mechanisms has for what types of cases we should select when using in-depth case study methods like Process-tracing. The article proceeds in three steps. We first expose the assumptions that underpin the study of causal mechanisms as systems that have methodological implications for case selection. In particular, we explore three less recognized aspects of taking mechanisms seriously: 1) the ontological assumptions of deterministic and set-theoretical relations that underpin the study of mechanisms, 2) the fact that different mechanisms leave different empirical fingerprints if they are conceptualized and operationalized properly, and 3) the challenge that equifinality at the mechanisms level poses for our ability to make cross-case inferences about mechanisms. Section 3 discusses why these aspects of mechanisms as systems make existing case selection techniques less appropriate, illustrating four deficiencies in existing guidelines. We first show why selecting a ‘typical’ case that is defined as a regression line ‘on-lier’ results in a serious risk of selecting a case where the theorized mechanism is not theoretically possible. Second, given that different mechanisms leave different fingerprints that can be distinguished from each other empirically, existing guidelines that suggest we need to isolate the workings of causes through selection of ‘pathway cases’ or ‘unique set members’ are irrelevant. Thirdly, we illustrate why the logic of most-likely and least-likely case selection is not compatible with the underlying ontological assumption of mechanisms as deterministic theories. Finally, due to the risk of causal heterogeneity at the level of mechanisms, we suggest that one cannot infer that a mechanism is present in a broader population when we have only found it in one studied case as is recommended by existing guidelines. Section 4 develops a set of guidelines that are more appropriate for designs that take mechanisms seriously. Complicating matters somewhat is the fact that there are two distinct research goals that can be accomplished by studying mechanisms: 1) learning about what links causes with outcomes by focusing solely on the mechanisms in-between (mechanism-centered design) and, 2) designs aimed at revising causal theories by combing the tracing of mechanism breakdown in deviant cases and comparing across cases (condition-centered design).
Institution: Aarhus University
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3183839834
Cites:
Cited by: 1
Related to: 9