Work

Institutional and Technology Architecture Interplay in the National Identity System of India (Aadhaar) and Implications for an Effective Privacy Regime

Year: 2018
Type: preprint
Abstract: India’s state-of-the-art ICT based biometric national identification system – Aadhaar covers nearly 90% of the 1.3 bn population. Aadhaar based public service delivery has also a seen substantial increase. A key aspect of its design was that Aadhaar was envisaged as an ICT platform that could enable a variety of services to be built on it. Further, it was to be executed in a Public-Private Partnership (PPP) mode. The Unique Identification Authority of India (UIDAI) initially implemented Aadhaar under a government directive. In the absence of a formal data protection regime in India, concerns were raised regarding the legal basis of privacy of citizens’ data. Subsequently, the Aadhaar Act, 2016 gave both UIDAI and Aadhaar a legal basis and provided for broad safeguards for privacy. In addition, UIDAI claims to use a technological architecture that protects privacy. Government’s emphasis on universal coverage, mandate of linking Aadhaar with sim cards, bank accounts, subsidies, welfare schemes and income tax, among others has led to concerns regarding privacy of citizens’ data. This is because linking these services through Aadhaar allows the government and also rogue entities unprecedented access to citizen data, more critically so in an environment of a nearly non-existent data protection regime. These concerns also reflect the social and political context. Supreme Court is currently hearing a case concerning the legal validity of the above issues and the constitutional validity of the Aadhaar Act. Researchers have focused on the benefits and challenges of and role of PPPs in implementing Aadhaar and Aadhaar as a platform for service innovation. However, there has been little theoretical work that links the choice of technology and the institutional mechanisms in influencing the privacy regime. Further, organizational structure, processes, and linkages among the various entities implementing Aadhaar influence privacy outcomes, rather than the technology alone. The social construction of technology by individuals and organizations underpins the outcomes. Further these are shaped by an external environment characterized by citizen’s low levels of digital and privacy management skills, involvement of a number of agencies both public and private, and inadequate design and outlook to deal with data privacy. Objectives We intend to develop a framework for data privacy in the context of various entities, process interlinkages and the technology platform that are a part of Aadhaar. We shall compare these with other national identity systems. We hope that the learning from this research would contribute to the policy regarding privacy in Aadhaar. Methods We adopt the single case study approach in this paper exploring the developments in Aadhaar from 2009 to 2018. The secondary sources of data are various government reports, media publications and journal articles. The primary sources are interviews with various functionaries and empirical studies covering enrolment and authentication, both at the level of user and agencies that deliver public services and interviews with beneficiaries.
Author: Rekha Jain
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3191631685
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10