Work

Pastoralists, politics and development projects: understanding the layers of armed conflict in Isiolo County, Kenya

Year: 2019
Type: report
Abstract: Pastoral counties of northern Kenya are expected to undergo massive change in the \ncoming years due to the government’s ambitious infrastructural development agenda. \nHowever, the area frequently experiences violence as a result of conflict between pastoralist communities, and also due to ethno-political contestations. Isiolo County is one \nsuch place where planned development projects and conflict risks coincide, making it \nan important case study for understanding how the future may unfold. \nThis Working Paper is written in the framework of a larger project called “Future Rural \nAfrica: Future-making and social-ecological transformation” by the Universities of \nBonn and Cologne and BICC (Bonn International Center for Conversion). BICC is interested in the kinds of claims that are being made on land and its resources and how \nthese may change the existing dynamics of organised violence. The Paper explores the \ncomplexity of existing conflict in Isiolo and the emerging effects of new plans and land \nclaims. At its most basic level, conflict between pastoral groups, or between pastoralists \nand farmers is motivated both by survival (pastoral mobility and access to water and \npasture in a climatically challenging area) and the accumulation of livestock wealth. \nPolitics, which is generally extended along ethnic lines, adds another layer to the inter-communal conflict through the need for political survival and the accumulation of \npersonal wealth. The devolution of many powers and budgets to county level since 2013 \nhas then raised the stakes for political power. Since plans for infrastructure have been \nmade known, tensions have emerged, and fears of exclusion and dispossession of customary land users through speculative land-grabbing and uncompensated state acquisition. With Isiolo being a hub of the illicit small arms trade, guns have become a conflict \nmultiplier at every level. \nThe county is highly securitised with several specialised police units. However, they lack \ncapacity and their actions have tended to be either inadequate or overly reactive and \ntheir relationship with communities is poor. As a result, day to day security of pastoralist \ncommunities and their livestock relies on the rather informal and unprofessional \nNational Police Reserve, who are armed by the state, and community members, who \npurchase their own arms through illicit markets. Politicians on occasion have also supplied arms and ammunition to communities. The Paper concludes that the various layers \nof conflict should be considered and addressed simultaneously, and that development is \na new and potent factor in conflict at both political and community levels. A careful, \ninclusive conflict-sensitive approach to development is essential, but this is unlikely to \nhappen if leaders look for personal power and gain.
Language: English
Subfield: Soil Science
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3192965996
Cites: 24
Cited by: 20
Related to: 10