Work

Organisaatiokulttuurin ja johtajuusidentiteetin merkitys matriisiorganisaatiomuutoksessa : case-tutkimus

Year: 2012
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This study explored the connection of organizational culture and leadership identity to the functionality of the matrix organization at the shift from divisional structure to matrix structure and later to its dismantling.This is a case study of an enterprise operating in numerous fields during the period 1988-2010 and it adopts a longitudinal approach.Key individuals' experiences of the matrix organization were elicited using both quantitative and qualitative methods, including theme interviews, standardized questionnaires, semantic differentials and illustrative presentations.The study therefore represents the so-called mixed methods approach.The theoretical framework of the study was structural contingency theory, according to which the operating environment of the organization imposes on the organizational structures both external and internal compatibility demands.In the study at hand contingency theory was extended in the direction of internal compatibility factors by analysing the conceptions of leadership, in other words, leadership identity internalized by representatives of the target organization.The study moreover ascertained how factors pertaining to organizational structure and organizational culture should correspond to each other.The structural changes implemented at the time of the research afforded an opportunity to empirically study the relationship pertaining between these factors.It emerged from the findings of the study that a hierarchical divisional structure suits better than a matrix organization for geographically decentralized activity in numerous fields in a stable environment.This corresponds to the claims regarding structural contingency theory.Culturally the so-called role-power culture prevailing in the target organization would appear to fit badly with the matrix organization, but better with the divisional organization.It was furthermore established that the role-power culture gives rise to a rigid leadership identity requiring unity of executive power, which is not supportive of the activities of a matrix organization.In the matrix power is shared in a novel way, and adapting to this is challenging and difficult for leaders socialized to the role-power culture, and especially for older leaders.According to the work at hand, the shift from a divisional organization to a matrix organization entails that a new kind of leadership identity be evolved.In enterprises operating in numerous fields, the matrix organization would appear to easily give rise to us-them interfaces which exacerbate the experiences of injustice of business units possibly differing widely from each other when the units are compelled to more or less acquiesce to the matrix functions in keeping with the main business mode of operation dominating in the matrix.In other words; it may be difficult for matrix functions to satisfy the various needs and demands of very different business activities in an enterprise operating in numerous fields.The contributions of the study are presented in the form of a series of propositions (statements) and models which can be utilized in the planning of organizational changes.These can also be used to enhance the chances of success in necessary organizational changes by assessing in advance the demands imposed by internal and external compatibility factors.When the operating environment of the organization calls for structural change the personnel should also possess the capability for change.If such is not the case, these capabilities must be cultivated or the key personnel must be replaced.If there is no genuine need for organizational change it would be as well to abandon the notion of organizational change and its implementation.
Author: Keijo Varis
Language: Finnish
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W319898694
Cites: 185
Cited by: 37
Related to: 10