Work

The Complementarity Of Being

Year: 2021
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This thesis argues that Western thinking may have unwittingly erred with respect to its application of the principle of noncontradiction. It is in the discovery of the quantum phenomenon, and specifically the measurable discontinuity of quantum behaviour, where this hidden error may have finally been revealed. \n\tThe thesis arrives at this conclusion through a critical ontological analysis of the quantum phenomenon as it is defined in Neils Bohr’s complementarity interpretation of quantum behaviour. The thesis employs a method of ontological analysis adopted from the German philosopher Nicolai Hartmann. This method includes the identification and suspension of historical dogma and the analysis of ‘actual data’, which includes the phenomena of our experience and the related history of ideas. The analysis suspends our traditional application of noncontradiction to the underlying world in order to determine whether an alternative application of noncontradiction may be possible based on the quantum phenomenon. It is hypothesized from this that the potential contradiction suggested by quantum discontinuity (and the source of the so-called quantum mystery) may be overcome by acknowledging first our own implication in and as part of the same world and present moment. \n\tThe thesis takes the position, also essentially held by Bohr, that the quantum phenomenon represents the limit of objective knowledge as defined by the Kantian cognitive framework. Unlike Bohr, however, the thesis argues that, by considering our own implication in and as part of the same world and present moment, the limit of the phenomena (and thus objective knowledge) is revealed as complementary, that is to say, both jointly completing and mutually exclusive. The thesis argues that the implications of this are profound and lead ultimately to the need for a reconceptualisation of not just the quantum phenomenon, but also the present moment, reality and our own embodied cognition.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3199304720
Cites: 85
Cited by: 1
Related to: 9