Internal and external validity of the DSM-IV attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder and oppositional defiant disorder symptoms among Australian primary school children : a confirmatory factor analysis multitrait-multisource approach
Year: 2002
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) multitrait-multisource (MT-MS) approaches have recently been advocated in the study of the internal and external validity of the di behaviour disorders such as Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (AD/HD) (Gomez, Burns, Walsh, & De Moura, in press; Burns, Walsh, & Gomez, in press).CFA MT-MS studies provide a better test of internal and external validity because they can dis the amount of variance attributable to the trait, source and error.To date, no studi examined the amount of trait, source and error variance in the DSM-IV AD/HD and Oppositional Defiant Disorder (ODD) symptoms using a CFA MT-MS approach.Investigations of the external validity of the AD/HD and ODD dimensions using a CFA MT-MS approach are also lacking.The current study had three major aims.The first was to compare CFA models of parent and teacher rated DSM-IV AD/HD and ODD symptoms.Seven models of AD/HD and ODD were tested, including the DSM-IV based model of separate inattention (IN), hyperactivity/impulsivity (HI) and ODD factors.T second aim was to provide a stronger test of the internal validity of the DSM-IV AD/ and ODD symptoms using a CFA MT-MS approach.This aim involved the determination of the amount of trait, source and error variance in the DSM-IV AD/HD and ODD symptoms at the matrix level, and individual symptom parcel level.The third aim was to provide a clearer test of the external correlates, or external validity, o AD/HD and ODD dimensions using a CFA MT-MS approach.Of particular interest were the trait factor correlations of the IN, HI and ODD dimensions with the trait compon of academic performance, global functioning, emotional problems, peer problems and prosocial behaviour.These trait correlations were compared with Pearson's correlati for corresponding relationships.Method: This study included 457 parent ratings and teacher ratings of Australian primary school children aged 5 to 14 years.Rating scal ix included the D S M -I V A D / H D and O D D Rating Scale, the Non-Clinician's Global Assessment of Functioning Scale (Setterberg, Bird, & Gould, 1992) and the Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire (Goodman, 1997).Results: Support for the DSM-TV three factor model of IN, HI and ODD was found for parent and teacher confirmatory factor analysis.CFA MT-MS findings indicated that this model also provided a good fit at the matrix level when source effects were removed.Parent rated HI and ODD symptom parcels, and teacher rated IN symptom parcels contained more trait than source variance supporting their convergent validity.However, all parent and teacher rated AD/HD and ODD symptom parcels contained significant source variance.Findings also indicated that the trait factor correlation between the HI and ODD traits was significant, suggesting these factors are highly correlated once source effects are removed.For the external validity analyses, Pearson's correlations indicated that IN, HI and ODD were all associated with academic performance, global functioning, emotional problems, peer problems and prosocial behaviour.The removal of source effects, however, indicated tha IN was associated with academic performance, global functioning and prosocial behaviour.HI was also associated with academic impairment, global functioning and prosocial behaviour, albeit to a lesser degree.Neither IN, HI, nor ODD were associated with emotional problems.ODD was associated with peer problems.Discussion:Although the DSM-IV three factor model of IN, HI and ODD was supported using CFA, there appears to be a high level of source effects in the symptoms, thereby questionin validity of this model.The CFA MT-MS findings also show somewhat different relationships for IN, HI and ODD with academic performance, global functioning, emotional problems, peer problems and prosocial behaviour than those established previously using Pearson's correlations.In view of the high source effects in most of AD/HD symptoms, the major implication for assessment/diagnosis is that the current x conceptualisation of A D / H D as being cross-situational m a y be incorrect or misleading.The major implication for understanding AD/HD and ODD is that the correlates of IN are academic performance, global functioning and prosocial behaviour.Academic impairment, global functioning and prosocial behaviour are also correlated with HI, al to a lesser degree.ODD is correlated with peer problems.It is argued here that the us a CFA multitrait-multisource design is a valuable methodology for furthering our understanding of AD/HD and ODD, as well as other childhood disorders.
Author: Melissa Keogh
Institution: Federation University
Language: English
Subfield: Psychiatry and Mental health
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Keywords: attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, oppositional defiant disorder, inattention, hyperactivity/impulsivity, parent and teacher ratings, factor structure, generalizability, internal validity, elementary school students, academic performance, peer problems, emotional problems, prosocial behavior, global functioning, Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire, Australian children
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3199583277
