Work

Widening Participation in Medicine: Conferences Build Confidence? [Letter]

Year: 2021
Type: article
Abstract: It is heartening to read of new Widening Participation (WP) initiatives.Social Mobility Foundation chief executive David Johnston said, "In reasonably similar proportions they want to be doctors … but the middle-class child expects to become the thing they aspire to, while the disadvantaged child does not".Confidencea key barrier to access.We commend the work by Ryan et al, 'Widening Participation in Medicine: The Impact of Medical Student-Led Conferences for Year 12 Pupils' for focussing on this. 1 2020 review of the evidence of the impact of interventions for widening access to higher education by Robinson et al, 2 reporting key findings and recommendations based on the evidence gaps, helpfully guides assessment of their initiative.It is encouraging that a one-day conference has potential to raise self-reported confidence levels significantly.However, there were many variables that make determination of the causal effects difficult.Conference A students received guidance throughout their presentation preparations, while those in conference B received none.Disadvantaged student's lack of knowledgeable support was highlighted by Martin et al to restrict their options for higher education.3 They do not feel represented and lack awareness of the realities of medicine.Literature review by Sanders and Higham showed that medical student rolemodels help establish a more accurate perception of the course, provide invaluable insight and instil confidence towards applications.4 Unsurprisingly, students in conference A felt more confident in five out of six assessed domains.Mentorship clearly contributes to confidence.WP initiatives should consider student-led mentoring schemes and not conferences alone, to reap benefits from both approaches.Conference A and B had different workshop types, medical vs soft skills respectively.It again makes for poor comparison, and it was unclear why those topics were chosen.Instead, students can easily suggest topics of concern on a preconference questionnaire, allowing organisers to design workshops aimed specifically at those issues.Components tailored to students' specific needs make for a more effective initiative, as supported by Robinson et al. 2 For better targeting, I agree that a tailored WP criteria is prudent. 1 It also captures the vulnerable mature and vocational students, a cohort that is still systematically missed. 2 Regarding funding, it was unclear what attributed to the higher cost incurred in conference A over B, and expenditure was not accounted for.This undermines the authors criticism of the financial costs limiting activities.Regardless, low-cost online conferences
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $2,320
OpenAlex ID: W3200432574
FWCI:
Cites: 4
Cited by:
Related to: 10