Work

A Constitutional Retreat

Year: 2006
Type: preprint
Abstract: In this paper Lord Cooke considers R (on the application of Jackson) v Attorney General [2005] UKHL 56, [2006] 1 AC 262, which was a challenge to the validity of the Hunting Act 2004. He describes the central issue in Jackson as being “whether the power to legislate without the consent of the House of Lords, which power was conferred by the Parliament Act 1911, could be exercised, as it was in the 1949 Act, to shorten certain time stipulations contained in the 1911 Act itself”. Lord Cooke first outlines the key legislative provisions and then turns to the reasoning of the House of Lords. He focusses on three key points. He first critiques the House of Lords’ statutory interpretation of the key legislation section, section 2(1) (as outlined by Lord Rodger). He then assesses the “political fact” argument (as discussed by Lord Hope). Thirdly, Lord Cooke stresses that case authorities could have led the House of Lords to recognise that there were “express limitations” to section 2(1) in the 1911 Act” that should prevail. Lord Cooke concludes, however, by noting that the outcome was unsurprising, but that the “retreat” of the House of Lords “may represent wisdom rather than timidity” and that history would be the ultimate judge. Abstract by Tim Cochrane
Author: Robin Cooke
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W339239967
Cites:
Cited by: 2
Related to: 10