Indirect Land-Use Change from BiofuelProduction : Uncertainties and Policymaking from an EUPerspective
Year: 2012
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Due to the continuous extensions of biofuel production, indirect land-use change (iLUC) has come under particular scrutiny in the past years, raising sparked interest in EU policy-making and science.Green house gas (GHG) emissions from iLUC are generally not denied.The debate about iLUC is rather concerned in how far these emissions influence the climatic performance of the biofuel's production life cycle.It seems to be clear that GHG emissions from iLUC are significant, though there is much scientific uncertainty in determining the estimation of emissions from iLUC.Thus EU policy makers are challenged to design appropriate policy frameworks in order to deal with iLUC emissions within the presence of scientific uncertainty.On top of this, policy makers are pressured in different directions by stakeholders.Generally speaking, NGO demand strict regulation on iLUC, while biofuel industry opposes such regulations.The aim of this thesis is to investigate how EU biofuel policymakers can handle the iLUC issue, given the scientific uncertainty and the involvement of stakeholders.The main issue discussed in this paper is how to design policy regulations for iLUC without an established reasonable degree of certainty.The uncertainty lies in modelling of iLUC but also within the difficulties of including iLUC emissions in Life Cycle Assessment (LCA).Therefore, the first part provides a sound and theoretical background and aims to explain how greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions are induced from iLUC.Also, main methodological features of LCA are presented.Furthermore, this chapter guides through the EU biofuel policy landscape to show recent enacted legislations associated to iLUC.The second part of this thesis contains an analysis, demonstrating why it is challenging to model iLUC and to include this phenomenon into LCA.Additionally, within this chapter it is analysed how EU policy regulators deal with this range of scientific uncertainty to design an appropriate policy framework.Followed by a discussion, the paper evaluates results, proving that setting policy decisions on iLUC in the presence of scientific uncertainty potentially runs the risk of limiting the attractiveness of the EU biofuel market.Alternatively, the inclusion of iLUC in EU policy could develop new opportunities to differentiate and promote the production of the most sustainable biofuels regarding their GHG emission performance.The importance of including stakeholder in decision-making processes is outlined.The issue around iLUC requires a holistic perspective in order to design regulations to reduce emissions most efficiently to achieve overall goals of the EU biofuel policy.This thesis finds out that the EU has not made any clear decisions which leads to investment insecurity in biofuel technology.As biofuel technology plays an important part to reach overall environmental EU goals, there might be a risk of not fulfilling them.The EU hesitates to make a decision on iLUC due to the pressure, coming from the biofuel industry and NGOs.The rather vague scientific evidences on iLUC has influenced the debate among EU policymakers.Past studies, research and policy papers have been done on published LCA studies and models to quantify GHG emissions from iLUC and therefore literature review is chosen as method for writing the present thesis.
Author: Taniya Offergeld
Language: English
Domain: Life Sciences
Open Access status: green
Funder: Lunds Universitet
OpenAlex ID: W364321515
