Managing the development assistance issue : the International Telecommunicatin Union and its structure of influence
Year: 1991
Type: dissertation
Abstract: l?fit: frjllowi~~g study examines the role of the Internabional Teleco~nmunication I:nicm (ITIT i n managing the emergence and evolution of the development assistance isstte wit.hin this international governmental organization (IGO).Unlike other post.-Warspecialized agencies, the ITlr was not creat.edwith any constitut.iona1rnandat,e t,o aclclress the developrnent needs of its member-stat.es.Yet, during the past.fort,y years, the ITlT has successf~~lly expanded its original focus from that of a technical fcmtni for t.he industrialized count*ries to become a full fledged aid organization under the auspices of t,he United Nations.Although this process was not accomplished over night nor wit.hout clissension, t, he ITU has been able t.o accornmodat,e the divergent.agendas of cleveloped and developing countries, thus avoiding major disputes or wit.ticlrawals which might ultimat,ely h e a t e n the survival of the organization.How has the ITIT managed to remain an effective international organization i t e s p te the ptirsuit of two clearly divergent agendas by its member-states'?The thesis seeks to address this primary research question using several methods of hvestigation.Document analysis and archival research was employed to examine the historical evolution of the ITU and its management of the development assistance issue.This was augmented by interviews and correspondence with a wide range of pla~ers int irnately knowledgeable wit 11 the organization's more recent development assistance itctiv~ties.In particular, these techniques were used to investigate how the organizatwn's structure of influence has unfolded with respect to one specific initiative esthblished under the aegis of the ITV, namely, the Centre for Telecommunicati~7ns Development.Rased upon this investigation, the study concludes that the ITU has been an efkc t ivc tnanager of the developn~ent assistance issue, adequately incorporating the distinct agendas represented within its membership.Several factors can account for this success.The first cortierlls the IT 1-'s const it utio~iat rtrrangeulrnts itrlil ctc(-isiotlmaking procedures.11-hich have been tlesible enough t.v acwnmlotfatz chat~gc%s irt orga~lizational orientation in response to the demands of its ulem\wrsliip.T hr sc.it~trtl pertains to a situation of complex interdependence tVhich inforllls the 1TI:'s organizational dynamics.In essence.bot,h developing and clevclopec-i coutlr ries iit:,~l>t that, the success of their respective agendas is 1.11tiniately tied to the c.tlntinurtI presence of the other.Interdependence is also encouraged 1)y the tt.cllnology w1tit:Ii t.he ITU seeks t,o address.Telecom~~~u~~icabions technology relies 011 l~itrsnoni~i~t,io~~ and standardization for its successful q x r a t ion, a factor which i-tssist.~ in prornot.iriqcompronlise and cooperation instead of intransigence and n~it.l~clri~wal.'Tfl?r T 7 1 -prp7wiir s a pariicl~idri:~ interesting case stlici>-fw and)-s~s.kktat~itsilr4 1t1 thfi5.i t 1.4 the oldest I C .0 w;lrhin the present syster:~ of I-mted Natlons spet~~al~zccl qencles.test~fyirig t o its ability to adapt to ongoing changes in the irtrcrrrat~onal pr~lttical environtnent.In addition, it enjoys near-universal membership amongst t h e c.a~tntrirrs of t lie world, mcorporating r he participation of both ppverrzmrrits anrl the private secto-.T h ~s factor gives some mdication of the myriad of rllf'fcrinq interests wfiicli the I;nion must seek t.o acldress.Despite ~t s tong history.the greatest periocl of upheaval for the organization rtirt nor occur until the 1Y.iOs and 1960s.The process of decolonialization brought an id1 tix of newly-independent countries to marly of the I Y M specialized agencies.rncluding the ITtr.Along with these new entrants came a new set of issues for the csrgan~aatioti to tackle.Principally.in fulfilling its task of coordinating international tctec.o~~lnniinir.ationsactivities, the tinion found itself in the challenging situation of seeking to tiltset the chnands of countries with highly sophist,icated t clet.omrt~~lnicatio~~ssysterns as well as those with extremely limited and often-oi~tclat.critechnology.I'nlike other post-War specialized agencies, however, the ITU was not created wit 11 arky const if utianal tnandate to address the development needs of its memberst atrs.I~lstzatl.t hro~igh such factors as its flexible amending procedures, the ITU has worked to espand its focus from that of a solely technical forum to become a full tlt4geci illd organization under the auspices of the Iinited Nations.This process was not acmmplistied over night nor without ctissension.Studying the means through which the ITIT has at tempted to incorporate the contentious question of development.assistance provides an interesting case study of how an international organization seeks ti:, manage issues through a structure of internal and external sources of iufluence.The organization of this study foilo~vs t!w 1:wsic cltronolopy of t tir ['TIT'S esperie~ice xith the cleveiopnirnt assistance issue.The first two chaprers ;, f the thesis are of an introductory mture.Chapter 1 presents it11 overview of t t ~t .ctifkrerif academic approaches to the study of internatiotlal organizations.For tlir ptlsp~~st's of . .analysis.:t concenhrat.es on three general roles ~-h i c h these instit~lt,ions arc sraetl t o fulfill, namely.inst,rur:lents of national policy, autotmuous ~nt.ernatiorlil1 sct.i:~rs a11c1 modifiers of state behnviour.Drawing from rhis body of literat,ure, t,he i1ti~t)trr.t.hen introduces the conceptual tools which will be employed in t. his study of t.brI T i 1, particularly the cor.cept of influence and how it has been applied t o the s t ~~c l y c,d i n t e r n a t .i / d organizat,ions.C'liapter 2 provides a brief introcfr.lctionto the Int,ernabional Telecommunication Irnion, inclucling it,s f~lnctions, orgatiizabiizrlitl st,rt~ct.ureand operating history.The chapter also disc~.~sses the arrival of the developing count~ries and the changing nai.1-re i ~l f the i~lt.ernat.io~ialtelecommunicat.io~isenvironment in terms of their impact, on the Vnion's opes-d t,' IOIIS.C'hapt,er 3 t,races t.he emergence of the clevelop~~ien t assis tance agerirla within the ITIT, showing how this new set of clernancls has had an increasingly sigrlificsnt.impact.on the organization.The new agenda's presence has extended frrom the wording of the ITU's basic instrtmient .to its resolutions, and fi~lally, t.o its strurt,r ire and programs.This dynamic is discussed first.within the larger frarnework of IrI'[.l'sPlenipotent.iaryC'onferences, then within the more specific context of t hr: JTIi1s Consultative C'onunit t.ees ( C'C'Is ).The cleveiopnlent assistance agencla's inc~irsirm into the C' ClIs is particularly significant.as these operating st,ruct.ureshave traditionally been dominated by t-he major indus trializect co1111 tries.C'hapt$ers 4 and .5 deal more specifically with the st,rr.lcture of i ~i f l u c ~m withirk and surrounding the ITU and how this has shaped recent develop~nents concerning the issue of assist.ance to the developing countries.Chapter 4 discusses the 198'2 Plenipotent.iaryConference as a turning point in the history of the iirlion and its . .t raditic,n;ti patterm of ~nfluence.It focii:jcs o r 1 hc>' *qi the i'l' E's new structure of irlfluerlce is n l m i f v s t it1 :.fie Report of tile IT[.'-sponsored hciependent C'ommissio:~ for Wcjrlci-CVide 'Teiecommunications Development, entitled The Mzssing Link.Chapter .5 extends this analysis by examining the implement.at,ion of one of the Report's key recon:m~endations, namely, the est.ablishment of the Cent,re for 'I'electimm~i~lications Development (C'TD).St.udying the case of t,he CTD provides a11 interesting example of how int.erna1 and external int,erest.scan coalesce t,o rletmmine the success or failure of an int,ernational organizat.ion'sprograms and ir~itiatives.The final chapter of the thesis examines the results of the most recent Pl~mpotent iary Conference in terms of how these latest developments represent the ct~lruination of a process whereby clevelop~nent assistance has come to enjoy equal organizational status with the Union's other technicai functions.Chapter 6 also contc~ins speculation about the future of development assistance activities at the ITU.Finally, the concl~isions of the thesis are presented in two sections: first, as they pertain to the ITLr's management of the development assistanLe issue, and secondly, regarding t lie exercise of influence within international organizations.This thesis is not without its limitations.Most of these stem from the difficnltty of tracing and measuring sources of influence within an international forurn like the ITIT.Despite its importance to the outcome of any political enterprise, influence does not easily lend itself to quantitative analysis.Based upon such factors its rzprttation, perceived knowledge or expertise.it exists most commonly in the form of hear-say and personal opinions.Even when influence seems to appear in written form --111 transcripts of conference proceedings or minutes from conlnlit tee meetings --the researcher 111ust proceed with caution.For instance, ITU conference delegates are often given an opporturiity to decide how their comments will be recorded in the fiual version of a proceeding's documentation.3 ~.Wallace and D. Singer, "Intergovernmental organizatmn In the global system, 1815-1964", Internatzonal Organtzatzon, 24.2, 1370, pp.245-7.4 ~.Gerbet, "Rime and Development", Internatzonal S o c d Sczence Journal, 29.1, 1577, p 7 ~tic-l~idr-, 5 1 1 r l t st~ilct lira1 elernent~ as some form of constitutional document whlch establishes the organization, ident~fying its aims and methods of operation, and apermanent headquarters to carry out on-going functions.By combining these three e*ssenttal criteria, an international organization can be defined as a formal.contmuous structurr, cons~slmg of members
Source: Summit (Simon Fraser University)
Author: Paul Irwin
Institution: Simon Fraser University
Language: English
Subfield: Development
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W406886110
