An exploration of whether Earth can be built from chondritic components, not bulk chondrites
Year: 2021
Type: article
Source: Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta
Author: Conel M. O'D. Alexander
Institution: Earth and Planets Laboratory
Language: English
Topic: Astro and Planetary Science
Subfield: Space and Planetary Science
Field: Earth and Planetary Sciences
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
Awards: THE ABUNDANCES AND ISOTOPIC COMPOSITION OF HYDROGEN IN GLASSES&MINERALS FROM CHONDRULES AND CAIS CAN POTENTIALLY PROVIDE INFORMATION ON THE IMMEDIATE ENVIRONMENT IN WHICH THEY FORMED AND/OR SUBSEQUENT MODIFICATION IN THEIR PARENT BODIES. IN THE INNER SOLAR SYSTEM END MEMBER VOLATILE SOURCES INCLUDE THE SOLAR NEBULA GAS AND WATER ICE; THESE TWO SOURCES HAVE D/H RATIOS THAT DIFFER BY UP TO AN ORDER OF MAGNITUDE AND ARE ALSO CHARACTERIZED BY VERY DIFFERENT O ISOTOPE COMPOSITIONS. ADDITIONALLY COUPLED DATA ON DEGREE OF HYDRATION AND O ISOTOPE COMPOSITIONS OF CHONDRULES AND CAIS CAN POTENTIALLY IDENTIFY OPEN-SYSTEM BEHAVIOR IN PHASES THAT ARE USED FOR AL-MG PB-PB SM-ND AND HF-W CHRONOMETRY. OBJECTIVES: WE WILL EXAMINE CHONDRULES AND CAIS IN THE MOST PRIMITIVE (I.E. THE LEAST METAMORPHOSED AND AQUEOUSLY ALTERED) CO CM CR AND CV CARBONACEOUS CHONDRITES AND THE ORDINARY CHONDRITES SEMARKONA AND MET00526 TO DETERMINE IF THEY (A) PRESERVE EVIDENCE FOR VOLATILES INCORPORATED FROM THE SOLAR NEBULA POTENTIALLY RECORDING THE PARTIAL PRESSURE OF HYDROGEN DURING THEIR FORMATION; AND (B) RECORD OPEN-SYSTEM BEHAVIOR FOR H O IN THEIR PARENT BODIES. NEBULAR SIGNATURES CAN BE OVERPRINTED BY LATER INTERACTIONS WITH LOW-TEMPERATURE H2O-RICH FLUIDS IN CHONDRITE PARENT BODIES ACCOMPANIED BY HYDRATION AND FORMATION OF MOLECULAR H2O IN GLASS THAT IS FAR IN EXCESS OF THE H2O/OH RATIO TYPICAL OF QUENCHED HIGH-TEMPERATURE MELTS. THIS EXCESS MOLECULAR H2O IS READILY OBSERVED BY FTIR (SO MUCH SO THAT IT HAS FORMED THE FOUNDATION OF AN H2O-DIFFUSION-BASED DATING METHOD FOR OBSIDIAN TOOLS IN ARCHAEOLOGY). WE WILL USE SEM EPMA SIMS FTIR AND RAMAN SPECTROSCOPY TO FOCUS ON DOCUMENTING THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN CONCENTRATIONS AND ISOTOPIC COMPOSITIONS OF H AND O IN CHONDRULES AND CAIS AND THE H2O/OH RATIO IN CHONDRULE GLASSES IN THE LEAST ALTERED AND METAMORPHOSED CHONDRITES IN ORDER TO DETERMINE THE SOURCES OF HYDROGEN PRESENT IN THE EARLIEST INNER SOLAR SYSTEM. OUR ULTIMATE AIM IS THE DETECTION OF NEBULAR H IN CHONDRULES AND/OR CAIS. THIS WILL BE CHALLENGING AS NOT ONLY DO WE EXPECT CONCENTRATIONS TO BE LOW (THOUGH LIKELY WITHIN THE SIMS DETECTION LIMITS OF OUR ~0.1 PPM) BUT WE MUST ALSO EXCLUDE THE POTENTIAL OVERPRINTING BY THERMAL METAMORPHISM AND/OR AQUEOUS ALTERATION. THIS STUDY WILL PROVIDE CONSTRAINTS ON THE VARIOUS MODELS THAT EXIST TO EXPLAIN CHONDRULE AND CAI FORMATION AND THE SOURCES OF ALTERING FLUIDS AND THE MECHANISMS OF FLUID-ROCK INTERACTION IN THE CHONDRITES. IN PAST WORK WE HAVE DEMONSTRATED A UNIQUE ABILITY TO DETECT VERY LOW LEVELS OF HYDROGEN SILICATE MINERALS AND GLASSES BY SIMS WITH DETECTION LIMITS BETTER THAN 0.1 PPM. ADDITIONALLY OUR PRIOR WORK ON LUNAR VOLCANIC GLASSES AND MELT INCLUSIONS HAS DEMONSTRATED THAT WE CAN OBTAIN RELIABLE DATA ON H ISOTOPES AT TOTAL H CONCENTRATIONS<0.6 PPM (5.4 PPM H2O) AND SPATIALLY-RESOLVED ANALYSES OF HYDROGEN ISOTOPES AT THE MICRON SCALE OBTAINED BY SCANNING ION IMAGING SIMS. WE ARE THUS IN THE BEST POSSIBLE POSITION TO ADDRESS THE PROBLEM OF IDENTIFYING AND CHARACTERIZING THE VOLATILE SIGNATURES OF THE HIGH-TEMPERATURE COMPONENTS IN CARBONACEOUS CHONDRITES. RELEVANCE: THIS STUDY WILL ADDRESS SEVERAL OBJECTIVES OF THE EMERGING WORLDS PROGRAM INCLUDING: (1) PROTOPLANETARY DISK FORMATION AND EVOLUTION (2) NEBULAR TRANSPORT MECHANISMS (3) LARGE-SCALE CHEMICAL AND ISOTOPIC FRACTIONATION PROCESSES (4) CHEMICAL PROCESSING OF GAS DUST AND ICE (5) THE CHEMICAL PROPERTIES OF ANCIENT MATERIALS (CAIS CHONDRULES) (6) EARLY THERMAL AND CHEMICAL PROCESSES OCCURRING ON SMALL BODIES AND (7) PROCESSES THAT OCCUR ON SOLAR-SYSTEM BODIES DURING THE PERIOD OF GLOBAL DIFFERENTIATION. THE PROJECT WILL SUPPORT A POSTDOC AT THE CARNEGIE INSTITUTION OF WASHINGTON AND PROVIDE ANALYTICAL SUPPORT FOR A GRADUATE STUDENT AT NORTHWESTERN UNIVERSITY., THE TWO MOST PRIMITIVE SOLAR SYSTEM MATERIALS AVAILABLE ARE CHONDRITE MATRICES (BOTH INTERCHONDRULE MATRIX AND CHONDRULE RIMS) AND CHONDRITIC POROUS INTERPLANETARY DUST PARTICLES (CP IDPS) AND BOTH CONTAIN PRESOLAR CIRCUMSTELLAR GRAINS D-RICH ORGANIC MATTER FINE GRAINED CRYSTALLINE SILICATES WITH SIMILAR RANGES OF COMPOSITIONS AND AMORPHOUS SILICATES. THESE COMMON FEATURES SUGGEST BOTH ARE MIXTURES OF MATERIALS INHERITED FROM THE PRESOLAR MOLECULAR CLOUD AND MATERIALS THAT WERE THERMALLY PROCESSED IN THE NEBULA. DESPITE THESE COMMON FEATURES THERE IS STILL NO CONSENSUS ABOUT (1) WHETHER MATRIX AND CP IDPS ARE RELATED (2) HOW THEIR COMPONENTS FORMED OR (3) WHAT THEY TELL US ABOUT PROCESSES IN THE EARLY SOLAR SYSTEM. IN THE TWO-COMPONENT MODEL MATRIX IS DOMINATED BY CI-LIKE MATERIAL. MODEST CONTRIBUTIONS FROM CHONDRULES AND INCLUSIONS ALONG WITH PARENT BODY MODIFICATION EXPLAIN NON-CI-LIKE BULK MATRIX COMPOSITIONS. THE HIGHER ABUNDANCES OF PRESOLAR GRAINS AND ORGANICS IN MANY CP IDPS INDICATE LOWER CONTRIBUTIONS FROM THE THERMALLY PROCESSED MATERIAL CONSISTENT WITH COMETARY ORIGINS. NEVERTHELESS FOR THE THERMALLY PROCESSED MATERIAL TO BE SO WIDESPREAD PROBABLY REQUIRES THAT IT FORMED VERY EARLY WHEN RADIAL DISK TRANSPORT WAS MOST VIGOROUS. THE ALTERNATIVE MODEL IS THAT MATRIX IS THE COMPLEMENT TO CHONDRULES IN WHICH CASE THE PRESOLAR GRAINS ORGANIC MATTER ETC. WERE ADDED TO MATRIX LATE IN A MINOR PRIMITIVE COMPONENT. COMPLEMENTARITY HAS FAR REACHING CONSEQUENCES AS IT SUGGESTS THAT CHONDRULES AND MATRIX FORMED IN CLOSE PROXIMITY AND WERE NOT LATER EFFICIENTLY FRACTIONATED FROM ONE ANOTHER DESPITE THEIR VERY DIFFERENT GRAIN SIZES. IT IS AN ARGUMENT AGAINST THE X-WIND MODEL AND ANY OTHER GRAIN SIZE SENSITIVE PROCESSES SUCH AS FORMING AND/OR TRANSPORTING CHONDRULES IN DISK WINDS OR PLANETESIMAL FORMATION BY PEBBLE ACCRETION OR THE STREAMING INSTABILITY. THESE TWO MODELS RESULT IN FUNDAMENTALLY DIFFERENT VIEWS OF THERMAL PROCESSING AND TRANSPORT IN THE NEBULA AS WELL AS ACCRETION OF PLANETESIMALS. IT IS THE AIM OF THIS PROPOSAL TO TRY TO TEST BOTH MODELS BY COMBINING FOCUSED ION BEAM (FIB) AND ELECTRON MICROSCOPY TECHNIQUES IN WAYS THAT MINIMIZE THE POTENTIAL FOR OPERATOR OR ANALYTICAL BIAS AS WELL AS PROVIDE CHECKS FOR THE ACCURACY AND SELFCONSISTENCY OUR PROTOCOLS. (I) WE WILL USE POINT COUNTING AND QUANTITATIVE ELEMENTAL ANALYSIS IN THE ELECTRON MICROPROBE TO DETERMINE THE ABUNDANCES AND BULK COMPOSITIONS OF: (A) CHONDRULES (B) ISOLATED METAL SULFIDE AND SILICATE GRAINS (>10 UM) (C) INTERCHONDRULE MATRIX (D) CHONDRULE RIMS AND (D) REFRACTORY INCLUSIONS. TO MINIMIZE THE INFLUENCE OF PARENT BODY ALTERATION WE WILL ONLY ANALYZE THE MOST PRIMITIVE CHONDRITES AVAILABLE. A FIRST ORDER CHECK OF THIS APPROACH WILL BE TO COMBINE ALL THE COMPONENTS IN EACH METEORITE AND COMPARE THE ESTIMATED BULK COMPOSITIONS TO THE BULK COMPOSITIONS FOR THEIR GROUPS FROM THE LITERATURE. (II) WE WILL FOLLOW THIS UP WITH HIGH SPATIAL RESOLUTION SEM STUDIES OF THE MOST PRIMITIVE MATRIX AREAS TO DETERMINE THE ABUNDANCES AND COMPOSITIONS OF MINERAL GRAINS>1 UM. THESE DATA WILL BE USED TO ESTIMATE THE CONTRIBUTIONS OF CHONDRULES AND INCLUSIONS TO MATRIX AS WELL AS TO SEARCH FOR GRAINS THAT ARE UNRELATED TO CHONDRULES AND INCLUSIONS. (III) WE WILL USE SEM-STEM AND TEM TECHNIQUES TO ANALYZE FIB SECTIONS FROM THESE MATRIX AREAS TO DETERMINE: (A) THE BULK COMPOSITIONS OF THE FIB SECTIONS FOR COMPARISON WITH THE MATRIX COMPOSITIONS DETERMINED BY EMPA AND (B) THE COMPOSITIONS MICROSTRUCTURES AND ABUNDANCES OF MINERALS AND AMORPHOUS MATERIAL>100 NM ACROSS (THICKNESS OF SECTIONS) FOR COMPARISON WITH CHONDRULES INCLUSIONS AND CP IDPS. WE WILL USE EXACTLY THE SAME TECHNIQUES TO ANALYZE FIB SECTIONS OF CP IDPS SO THAT WE CAN MAKE DIRECT COMPARISONS. ARMED WITH THIS DATA WE WILL COMPARE THE COMPOSITIONS AND MICROSTRUCTURES OF MATRIX AND ITS COMPONENTS TO THE EXPECTATIONS OF THE TWO-COMPONENT AND COMPLEMENTARITY MODELS.
OpenAlex ID: W4200331892
