Intimate Partner Violence
Year: 2010
Type: article
Abstract: After completing this article, readers should be able to: You are seeing a healthy 4-month-old infant for a health supervision visit. As part of a routine social history, you inquire about intimate partner violence (IPV). The infant's mother discloses that her partner frequently yells at her, pushes her, and makes her feel afraid. On additional questioning, she describes the infant as “fussy.” The baby's physical examination findings are unremarkable, but you note that he missed his 2-month visit and is behind on his immunizations. How do you proceed?Family violence and domestic violence often are used synonymously and refer to violence occurring between any family member dyad, including parent-child, intimate partner-intimate partner, or sibling-sibling. IPV refers specifically to violence perpetrated between romantic partners and has been defined by the Family Violence Prevention Fund as “a pattern of purposeful coercive behaviors that may include inflicted physical injury, psychological abuse, sexual assault, progressive social isolation, stalking, deprivation, intimidation and threats. These behaviors are perpetrated by someone who is, was, or wishes to be involved in an intimate or dating relationship with an adult or adolescent victim and are aimed at establishing control of one partner over the other.” (1) Over the course of a lifetime, between one fourth and one third of women in the United States are abused by an intimate partner. Every year, 2 to 4 million women and 0.5 to 1 million men report IPV victimization. IPV occurs in families of all races, ethnicities, and socioeconomic classes. Certain sociodemographic factors, however, have been associated with increased risk of IPV, including young age (with the highest rates in women 18 to 24 years old), lower socioeconomic status, mental health problems, and substance abuse. Separated or divorced women report higher rates of IPV than married women. Male-perpetrated IPV initially was recognized as a significant public health problem in the 1960s. Since that time, experts have achieved a greater understanding of the epidemiology and health consequences of male-perpetrated IPV. However, recent peer-reviewed papers and population-based surveys have reported that women perpetrate IPV as often as or more frequently than do men (2). These studies often are limited by failure to identify acts of self-defense and to recognize that men are much more likely than women to incite fear. (3) Despite the prevalence of female-perpetrated IPV, women still remain significantly more likely than men to be injured or killed by their partners.Fifteen million children in the United States are exposed to IPV each year. (4) Almost 50% of these children are exposed to severe IPV, such as one parent beating up another parent or one parent using a knife or gun against another parent. (4) Rates of IPV are disproportionately high in families who have children younger than 5 years of age. Childhood exposure may include being present in the room while the violence is occurring, overhearing the violence from another room, or observing the aftermath of a violent argument, including parental injuries or destruction of property. It is unclear whether exposure to male- or female-perpetrated IPV affects child health differentially, and most of the literature on the IPV-child health relationship focuses on the impact of male-perpetrated IPV. Therefore, the remainder of this review focuses predominantly on male-initiated violence.In 1998, the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) recommended routine IPV screening during health supervision visits, stating that “identifying and intervening on behalf of battered women may be one of the most effective means of preventing child abuse.” (5) This statement was based on the well-documented overlap between child maltreatment and IPV. Although the associations between physical IPV and child maltreatment are most prominent in the literature, risk for child maltreatment also is elevated in families in which intimate partners engage in psychological abuse. In populations of families either reported to Child Protective Services (CPS) for child maltreatment or in domestic violence shelters, the co-occurrence of child maltreatment and IPV ranges from 30% to 60%. (6)(7) Rates of overlap between IPV and child maltreatment in community-based samples are notable, although lower than rates in high-risk samples. Poverty, parental depression, and substance abuse increase the risk of co-occurrence.Children living in homes where IPV occurs also may be injured inadvertently by being “caught in the crossfire” of parental altercations. (8) Infants and toddlers may be injured if they are being held in a parent's arms during a physical altercation. Older children, on the other hand, may be injured while trying to intervene to stop a fight.Since the 1980s, increasing attention has been focused on infants and children as the “silent victims” of IPV, and research related to the social-emotional health consequences of childhood IPV exposure has grown exponentially. Childhood IPV exposure likely leads to adverse child health through a number of pathways, including trauma, altered stress physiology, and disruption of the caregiver-child attachment relationship. Children exposed to IPV also frequently perceive the world as hostile and unsafe and learn via social modeling that aggression is an acceptable means through which to resolve conflict. Strong evidence links childhood IPV exposure with a wide variety of adverse social-emotional health outcomes in childhood. (9) Specific problems vary according to age and developmental stage but include developmental delay, depression, anxiety, peer aggression, and posttraumatic stress disorder/hypervigilance. Infants may display symptoms of trauma, including excessive crying and resisting comfort. IPV also may disturb infant routines such as sleeping and feeding and may affect maternal-infant attachment. Common symptoms in toddlers include extreme separation anxiety, excessive tantrums, and aggression with peers.School-age children living in homes in which IPV occurs are more likely than their peers to exhibit aggressive and antisocial behaviors and are more likely to be anxious, fearful, and hypervigilant. IPV exposure in school-age children also has been linked with poor peer relations, perhaps due to poor self-esteem and sensitization to hostility. Adolescents in homes where IPV is present have higher rates of school failure, substance abuse, and risky sexual behaviors. These adolescents are more likely than their peers to enter into a violent dating relationship.Research about the impact of IPV on children's physical health and health-care use is in its infancy, although some patterns are emerging. Compared with peers, children exposed to IPV are less likely to attend health supervision visits and to be fully immunized and are more likely to have emergency department visits. Children exposed to IPV also may incur greater overall health-care costs than their peers. Less is known about the impact of IPV on children's physical health, although recent studies have associated IPV exposure with a higher incidence of childhood asthma and with infant failure to thrive and childhood malnutrition. (10) Childhood IPV exposure also affects adult health adversely. Felitti and colleagues (11) published a series of articles examining the association between “adverse childhood experiences,” including exposure to a battered mother, and a host of adult health outcomes. The authors enrolled more than 20,000 men and women and found a consistent, graded relationship between the number of adverse childhood experiences and poor adult health outcomes. When analyzed separately, exposure to a battered mother was consistently linked with adverse adult health sequelae ranging from depression to substance use.Screening caregivers for IPV may improve the pediatric clinician's understanding of the child's current illness, home environment, and ability to follow physician recommendations. Screening also communicates that IPV is a common public health problem, reduces the isolation commonly associated with IPV, and conveys that IPV exposure affects children. In addition, abused women may be more likely to seek health care for their children than for themselves, making the pediatric setting an important site for screening. Mothers generally support screening for IPV in the pediatric setting and feel that the pediatric office is a safe location to discuss IPV and its consequences. Most major medical organizations (AAP, American College of Obstetrician-Gynecologists, American Medical Association) recommend routine IPV screening. It is unclear, however, whether screening leads to short- or long-term benefits for women. MacMillan and colleagues (12) recently found that female patients randomized to IPV screening, compared with nonscreened control women, did not report decreased IPV or increased health or quality of life over time. In 2004, the United States Preventive Services Task Force published guidelines stating that there was not sufficient empiric evidence to recommend either for or against routine IPV screening. (13) Criticisms of these guidelines include: 1) Asking about IPV should be viewed as a routine behavioral health inquiry rather than as a “screening test”; 2) Benefits of screening may extend beyond decreasing violent episodes, and these benefits should be considered in evaluating the merits of screening; and 3) IPV is a complex issue, and qualitative research or studies outside of the traditional medical literature should be considered. Benefits and risks for children related to screening mothers for IPV remain uninvestigated.Options to routine screening include no screening or performing targeted screening. In the pediatric setting, targeted screening includes children in whom concern exists for child abuse and neglect. Pediatric clinicians also should be concerned about IPV based on findings for both the mother and child. They should be concerned if the patient's mother appears depressed or overly anxious, has obvious physical injuries, repeatedly cancels or misses appointments or has difficulty following through with medical advice, or is abusing alcohol or other drugs. In addition, concern is raised if the child has emotional problems, including depression, anxiety, or attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder, and has frequent nonorganic symptoms, such as headaches or stomachaches. In addition, certain situational factors may precipitate IPV, including pregnancy, parental separation or divorce, or efforts to leave the current relationship. The risk of a targeted screening approach, however, is that many women affected by IPV will not be identified.When screening patients’ mothers, the topic of IPV can be introduced with a statement such as: “The safety and well-being of mothers affects the safety and well-being of children, so I ask all mothers a number of questions about themselves and about their safety.”The psychometric properties of numerous IPV screening questions have been tested in health-care settings. The general consensus is that precise, behaviorally anchored questions are more sensitive and specific than are general questions such as “Do you feel safe at home?” or “Are you a victim of IPV?” A comprehensive compendium of IPV screening questions, published by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, can be found at http://www.cdc.gov/NCIPC/pub-res/images/IPVandSVscreening.pdf. Notably, most of the validated IPV screening instruments have been tested exclusively on women; two sets of screening questions have been validated in a pediatric setting.When a child 3 years of age or older is in the examination room, abused women have expressed concern about clinicians using behaviorally anchored questions. (14) When these older, verbal children are present, women worry that the child may be traumatized or later inadvertently relay the conversation about IPV to the perpetrator. If the child and mother can be separated (such as during hearing and vision screening), clinicians can screen the mother when she is alone. If not, the clinician should use more general questions such as “How do you and your partner work out arguments?” and “In general, how would you describe your relationship with your partner: a lot of tension, some tension, or no tension?” Attention to the response and to nonverbal cues is important. If the response or the reaction to these questions is a concern, the clinician should attempt to interview the woman alone to pursue more specific questions. A woman may answer “no” many times before she discloses.In the pediatric setting, the child is the patient, and both legal guardians have access to the medical record. If the perpetrator is the child's father, he has access to the chart and could become aware of the caregiver-clinician IPV conversation, potentially increasing the risk of violence. In contrast, it may be legally beneficial (eg, in restraining orders or child custody cases) to document IPV in the child's medical record. Although the risks of documentation are more theoretical than evidence-based, it is important to discuss the risks and benefits of documentation with the mother and abide by her wishes. A second option is to include in the chart a code known to other clinicians in the practice that would not be readily understandable to others, such as +MIPV (for positive maternal IPV). Although there is a dearth of empiric data about effective interventions in reducing IPV victimization or perpetration or in improving health, the following responses to a positive IPV screen are recommended: 1) An empathetic statement supporting the woman and emphasizing that she does not deserve to be treated that way; 2) Questions about escalation of violence, weapons, and comfort in going home to assess the woman and child's current safety; 3) Detailed history and physical examination looking for possible child abuse; 4) Provision of social work assistance or national (1-800-799-SAFE) and local IPV resources; 5) Planning for safety (Table); and 6) An assessment of whether the child would benefit from mental health intervention or from frequent visits with his or her primary care clinician. If violence is escalating or the family is in immediate danger, safe housing must be established, which IPV hotlines can help to facilitate.Most IPV organizations offer shelter and counseling as well as legal and social advocacy for abused women. Therefore, pediatricians should familiarize themselves with the services offered by local IPV organizations. If the woman wishes, call the hotline from the pediatric office. The pediatric office also may be a safe place for an IPV advocate from a local organization to meet the woman to provide assistance. Establishing a trusting caregiver-clinician relationship is critical, and clinicians should recognize that addressing IPV and helping women make positive changes often takes time.Clinicians should recognize that advising the woman to leave the relationship may not be the safest solution for her or her children. The risk of homicide for women increases by 75% around the time of leaving an abusive relationship. Further, leaving an abuser may mean going into a shelter, removing children from their current schools, and losing significant economic support.With any disclosure of IPV, a careful assessment of the child's well-being and safety is essential. Pediatric clinicians are obligated to report to CPS any suspicion of child abuse or neglect or any concern that the child is in imminent danger. It can be helpful to have the mother file the report with the clinician and to document, as appropriate, ways in which she has attempted to protect the child. CPS should be made aware of the co-occurring IPV, and planning for safety is critical. States vary regarding whether pediatric reporters are mandated reporters of childhood IPV exposure. Some states’ laws explicitly say that pediatric clinicians are mandated reporters of childhood exposure to IPV. In other states, it is not explicitly written. However, case law has interpreted IPV exposure as falling under emotional abuse, thereby making pediatric clinicians mandated reporters. In some states, health-care clinicians also may be mandated reporters of IPV. Clinicians should know their specific state's reporting requirements prior to screening. Websites such as www.endabuse.org or http://www.childwelfare.gov/ may help discern state-specific laws about mandated reporting.If practicing in a state that has mandated reporting laws for either IPV or childhood exposure to IPV, clinicians should inform the mother of their responsibility to report before screening. If practicing in a state that has less specific reporting laws and there is no suspicion of child maltreatment, the pediatrician should consider each situation individually to determine what is best for the child and mother.Although proponents of mandated reporting for childhood IPV exposure state that reporting is justified due to the negative health outcomes, others are concerned about such requirements. Apprehension about mandated reporting for IPV exposure stems from fear that reporting is punitive to the victim, implying that she failed to protect the child. Universal reporting also incorrectly assumes that all children are affected similarly by IPV exposure and may increase demands on an already overburdened CPS. Mandated reporting decreasing women's likelihood of disclosing IPV and seeking help also is a concern.
Source: Pediatrics in Review
DOI: 10.1542/pir.31.4.145
Author: M. H. Bair-Merritt
Institutions: Johns Hopkins University, Johns Hopkins Medicine
Language: English
Subfield: Health
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W4206392708
