Work

Vergil's Apprenticeship. II

Year: 1920
Type: article
Abstract: VERGIL'S "CIRIS" AND MESSALLA It is not my intention to review the mass of material that concerns the authorship of the Ciris.The masterly discussions of Drachmann (Herm., 1908, pp.405 fF.) and Vollmer (Sitz.Bayer.Akad., 1907, pp.335 ff.) have summed up the most important argu- ments in favor of the Vergilian claim, and these seem to me conclusive.But here also the right decision has failed to carry due weight because the defenders of the poem have not discovered a reasonable historical setting for it.The following considerations may perhaps aid in the removal of the persistent doubt.In the first place, the certainty that Vergil addressed Catalepton ix to Messalla adds a heavy weight of probability in favor of the Vergilian authorship of the Ciris, not only because it helps to vindicate the tradition on which both rest, but also because it establishes the certainty that Vergil and Messalla were on the very terms of friendship that the dedication of the Ciris assumes.Striking also is the occurrence in both poems of the unusual phrase communem deum (Ciris 359; Cat.ix.50), which indicates a common author for both poems, since neither was published for the time being.But the strongest point for the Ciris gained from the eulogy is in the explicit statement of Vergil that he was a student of Callimachus, and that presumably in some poem of special interest to Messalla.
Author: Tenney Frank
Language: English
Subfield: Classics
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4206842907
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by: 2
Related to: 10