Work

Editorial

Year: 1979
Type: editorial
Abstract: The appearance of a new textbook** Cutler, P. (1979) Problem Solving in Clinical Medicine, pp. 373. The Williams and Wilkens Company, Baltimore. Price $20.75. by Dr Cutler of the Health Service Centre, University of Texas at San Antonio raises again the awkward issue of the standing of the problem-solving method. Despite indications of its good educational potential and vigorous advocacy by its protagonists, medical teachers remain uncertain about its usefulness and its actual use in training doctors still seems extremely limited. It is true that two new medical schools, McMaster in Canada and Newcastle in Australia, have given a central place to problem-solving learning, but it is probably fair to say that by and large medical teachers continue to be sceptical. Cutler takes medical educators seriously to task for making their teaching disease oriented rather than patient-problem oriented. His book sets out to teach the student how to find out what is wrong with the patient. He deals first with the principles and mechanisms of problem-solving; he then instructs his readers how to select key items from the data base; a third section of the book consists of case presentations, demonstrating problem-solving in action; the final section includes special aspects of problem-solving, in psychiatric, paediatric and geriatric work. His collaborators are the clinical staff of the San Antonio Center, who illustrate the teaching approach with problems from the different branches of medicine. Examples are given ‘of more than 25 methods of problem solving called upon daily by the clinician’. Among these are thirteen clinical methods, including: the traditional method branching technique early hypotheses clusters syndromes key clues pattern recognition suppression of information pattern building hunch proof by exclusion Lanthanic method, and the anatomical approach. He also discusses six mathematical techniques, including sets, Venn diagrams, Boolean algebra, Bayes’ theorems, dendrograms and computer methods. Although Cutler's book is intended for medical students (and for continuing education of doctors), medical teachers will gain much clarification from it about the problem-solving approach in teaching. Not surprisingly, some medical teachers ignore claims that problem-based learning merits their attention, expecting that like other short-lived wonders and transient fads this educational development will wither and disappear. Others, who have taken the trouble to investigate what the method is about, may dismiss it as mere verbiage, or pretentious jargon, untested and hence of dubious educational value; they will point to the major upheaval to which students and teachers will be subjected were it to be adopted; they will register that medical teachers have many other responsibilities besides being continuously available for consultation with students intent on problem-solving. Less extreme opponents may still argue for conventional teaching of the basic subjects, so that the student can acquire a foundation of scientifically valid factual knowledge before he converts his conceptual approach from a relatively passive-receptive one, to active learning deriving from the actual effort to solve problems. The main weakness of this argument, indeed, the absolute objection to it, is that problem-based learning is intended to inculcate intellectual habits necessary for active learning. The student is held to derive the capacity for continuous learning from the approach, to serve him throughout his professional life. Why then use allegedly bad practices in teaching the preclinical subjects, and require an intellectual switch only halfway through the curriculum—particularly when one of the assets claimed for the problem-solving approach is ongoing integration of clinical work with scientific knowledge? The corresponding objection, often heard, is that unless the entire curriculum is taught along problem-solving lines the method cannot be used. It is interesting that this was the position taken by Professor Rufus Clarke, the chairman of the Undergraduate Education Committee at Newcastle, Australia. He has changed his mind‡† Clarke, R. (1979)‘Why Learn Through Problem-Solving’. July Newsletter, The Centre for Medical Education Research and Development, University of New South Wales, Australia. p. 10. , however, and now considers that problem-based learning might be introduced in an existing curriculum,‘perhaps in a circumscribed segment devoted to, say, paediatrics or obstetrics’. Doctors, it can be claimed, should be trained by encountering and solving the problems which will be their responsibility in professional life. Problem-based learning does two things. As already indicated, the approach promotes proper methods of learning, which can serve as a life long basis for continuous learning. Second, it provides systematic training in solving problems. In the conventional curriculum, almost no formal attention is paid to the steps in differentiating patients' problems, the process of decision-making by the doctor, and the basis for subsequent clinical action. The further judgment and skill needed to negotiate a treatment regimen with a patient, and to monitor progress perhaps by collaboration with health team colleagues is scarcely mentioned. The problems selected as the basis for study are the initial step in a learning sequence. They can never cover the entire subject area, but with the emphasis on the procedure of problem solving, the student ought to proceed sensibly when confronted by conditions he has not previously encountered. The teacher's task is of course very different from that applicable in a conventional curriculum. Much ingenuity is required to provide the necessary learning resources, and self-study on the part of the student becomes primary. Once the problems have been selected by the teachers and suitably presented to the student, he will need relevant books and journals, and teachers to approach as consultants; the use of patients as clinical material has to be augmented by a range of other learning resources: models, manikins, stimulators, simulated patients, patient management problems, and tape-slide programmes;‘portable patient problem packs’, resourcefully devised by Barrows‡‡ Barrows, H.S. & Tarnblyn, R.M. (1977) The Portable Patient Problem Pack: a Problem-based Learning Unit. Journal of Medical Education, 52, 1002. , are the type of imaginative development of material that can further promote individual effort by students, and computer assisted learning is another extension of the same process. Perhaps a chief asset of this promising but arrested development in contemporary medical education is that it is only possible with concerted and cooperative effort by numerous teachers—one reason for its not taking off may be that such unity of purpose and action is rare and arduous in an established school. (It may be easier in a new school, where teaching staff can be recruited for a shared educational orientation, and where—initially at any rate—student numbers may be smaller.) A final requirement, needless to say, is that the evaluation procedures used should be structured to test problem-solving abilities, and not the ability to memorize and recall facts which current examinations mainly assess. Clearly, even interested medical teachers, daunted by the complexities and the obstacles, may not themselves be able to introduce problem-based learning in their own teaching. They will need to look for evidence about the value and effectiveness of the approach, from the few schools able to institute it. That calls for particularly responsible educational research at these centres, a large undertaking when already they have pioneered an educational development which should be of great interest to all medical teachers. This exceptional book presents an analysis of one of the most important public institutions in Britain. We all participate in the Health Service as patients or as providers of care. Professor Mackenzie has illuminated our roles and our often ambivalent attitudes to the institution in a remarkable way. His style is direct, personal, kindly and humorous. There is no over-simplification of complex issues but also no beating about the bush. Every point is meticulously documented. References and index are scholarly. And yet the book makes compulsive reading. One cannot put it down and is tempted to read long passages aloud. The book is astonishingly informative about the politics of the NHS. Many of one's pet notions are confirmed but explained in an historical context. The author IS totally accurate in his perception of the practicalities, for patients and staff, of everyday life in the NHS. Every sentence rings true. This gives one confidence that his sociopolitical analysis is equally just. The effect on the medical reader is both reassuring and invigorating. Two introductory chapters deal with the concepts of power and responsibility. A third focuses on the concepts of health; of health care systems; of need, health concerns and action; and on the Asclepian principles of individual care versus the Hygiean concerns with disease as the enemy of human groups. There follow the four central chapters on ‘What is a patient?… a doctor?… a nurse?… a hospital?’ A few quotes will perhaps convince the readers of this notice that they must buy the book. After an account of complaints procedures and patient associations, Professor Mackenzie writes ‘The balance of this chapter may seem to suggest that “the patient” once humble in the face of medicine, is now armed with so many weapons of offence and defence that the balance of power has changed, and medicine has been weakened so far that it operates under impossible conditions. … In fact, they (institutions for patient protection) may be regarded as an expression not of patient power but of patient anxiety. We are all at heart frightened at the combined strength of doctor, nurse, and hospital ….’ It may surprise us to know that ‘The UK system was from the outset … generous to the unqualified, and states its aim modestly: “Whereas it is expedient that persons requiring medical aid should be enabled to distinguish qualified from unqualified practititioners. …” It is not an offence to offer medical advice without being a “registered medical practitioner”…‘ There is a brief but illuminating section on medical education and an excellent account of organizations of doctors. ‘Traditionally, the BMA is politically inept, the Royal Colleges are slow to move, the average doctor, whether GP or specialist, is politically rather naive. But the system is held together by its peculiar relationship with the Ministry of Health …. In one sense, all doctors … are its clients …. In another sense, the DHSS is weak, it cannot move without the doctors.’ The Salmon and Briggs reports are brilliantly described. Salmon, implemented at once, was based on industrial management principles of the turn of the century rather than on observations. (‘One hardly knows how to cope with this stuff in tellectually.’) The work of the nurse up to and including the ward sister can be accurately specified.‘As one goes higher up the management hierarchy, the vague words proliferate: top managers are apt to find themselves defined as “co-ordinating”, “informing”, “liaising”, “communicating”… it has baffled empirical researchers to define what top managers “really” do, and how one distinguishes (except by triumph or disaster) between a good leader and a bad one.’ Hospices and infirmaries were the forerunners of the modern hospital.‘If one can slip unnoticed into the corridor of a general hospital (which is easy) one's impression … is one of vagueness, planlessness and irresponsibility. This is not an irrelevant impression; a hospital is in some sense a loosely constructed self-motivating institution. But discipline is there.’ Three final chapters on ‘Communication and information’, ‘What is the Government’ and on ‘Myths and contradictions’ conclude a book which will inform and enliven discussion among all students of medicine in the widest sense, whatever their age. The timing of its publication, coinciding with that of the Report of the Royal Commission on the Health Service, has been impeccable.
Author: Sula Wolff
Language: English
Subfield: Family Practice
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4210602755
Cites:
Cited by: 5
Related to: 10