Year: 1999
Type: editorial
Abstract: We have found in our interactions with companies concerning their system development activities that organizations frequently have a number of failed systems in their closets!In this issue, a very timely paper addresses just this subject.Kalle Lyytinen and Dan Robey, in their paper `Learning failure in information systems development', argue that one reason for this is what they call the collapse of organizational intelligence in organizations.By this they mean that, although organizations may embrace learning concepts, particularly from external sources, they are unable to embrace the change required and to translate this into effective learning.Some organizations have been failing for so long that they have learned to fail and this becomes the norm.The paper uses two cases studies to illustrate these problems.The authors then go on to identify four major reasons why organizations learn to fail: limits on organizational intelligence, discincentives for learning and organizational design and educational barriers.In conclusion, they then make suggestions to help overcome these barriers.The disincentive issue rings particularly true to us as we have seen situations where failure has been hushed up to the extent that others in systems development had no opportunity to learn from the mistakes.We hope that this paper will enable some organizations to break this cycle of failure.Our second paper is from Feng Li and Howard Williams and contributes to our understanding of the potential of interfirm collaboration beyond traditional EDI.Like the first paper, it uses case studies to identify examples of the changing nature of such collaboration and the development of important strategic collaboration rather than simple lower level operational interactions.One of the cases shows how an organization moved from standard electronic trading to the exchange of design information, which enabled the retailer to respond given its position close to the market to the mutual benefit of both organizations.Having identified these new dimensions of collaboration, a survey examines the situation in the electronics industry in Scotland, but this reveals that relatively few organizations in this sector have gone beyond the electronic exchange of hard trading information.Li and Williams, again as in the previous paper, identify a number of barriers that prevent organizations from reaping more strategic benefits from their network collaborations.Our third and fourth papers are both concerned with modelling.That of Victor van Reijswoud, Hans Mulder and Jan Dietz deals with communicative action modelling of business processes and information systems.The underlying frame of reference is that of Speech Act Theory, which considers the use of language as a form of rule-governed behaviour, a subject on which the Information Systems Journal has previously published a number of papers and which is identified as an increasingly influential approach in information systems.The authors argue that this approach is capable of handling the requirements of the turbulent environment and providing the flexibility that is essential to modern organizations.They discuss DEMO, which is their
Source: Information Systems Journal
Language: Spanish
Subfield: Management Information Systems
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4210646160
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to:
