Work

JacksonV. P., HollandJ. M., & Miller ArlineJ. R. (Eds.) (2021). African Americans in the human sciences. Lexington Books. ISBN 978‐1‐7936‐4894‐5 (hardcover). 306 pp.

Year: 2022
Type: book-review
Abstract: The scholarship and achievements of Black home economists/human scientists have long been marginalized. In that vein, African Americans in The Human Sciences: Challenges and Opportunities is an essential body of work. The editors themselves are examples of strong Black female leadership. Vanessa P. Jackson is the Department Chair for Retailing and Tourism Management at the University of Kentucky. Jaqueline M. Holland, CFCS, serves as the interim director for the Family and Consumer Sciences department at Morgan State; notably, she was honored with the AAFCS Distinguished Service Award in 2020. Julia R. Miller Arline was a founding member of the National Coalition for Black Development in Family & Consumer Sciences (NCBDFCS) and is a Dean and Professor Emeritus from Michigan State University. All three have served in multiple leadership roles, too numerous to mention here, throughout their careers, providing this text with the authority of their collective expertise. The book is organized into five sections with a short introduction by the editors for each. Part I includes seven chapters on Women, Education, and Careers. The first chapter, Quest for Education: Empowerment of Women of Color, is a collaboration between editor Julie R. Miller Arline, Debra L. Mayfield, and William H. Whitaker Jr. exploring the unique challenges that Black, Indigenous, and People of Color (BIPOC) women have had and continue to face in the arena of higher education, including combating stereotypes that they are unfit for leadership. “(D)espite struggles encountered, women of color have made unbelievable advancements in their educational journeys. Personal attitudes, families, and communities have significantly supported women of color in reaching the heights of their educational visions” (p. 12). Understanding this perspective is essential for anyone in higher education, particularly those that can influence policy and culture to become more inclusive. In the next chapter, Miller Arline and co-editor Vanessa P. Jackson offer a field guide to resilience for Black women who aspire to leadership in African American Women’s Pathway to Leadership Success: Resilience to Challenges Built on Mentoring and Spirituality. Interviewing ten African American women in Human Sciences leadership positions, they identified common factors they believe allowed these women to preserve through systemized challenges to achieve their dreams. Participants described finding and establishing mentors outside the higher education system when mentors who looked like them were nowhere to be found. Interviewing participants identified through the “snowballing method” was also the research that informed Chapter 3 Professional Working Women: A Qualitative Look at African American Mothers. Author Nina Lyon Bennett illustrates the historical complexities surrounding motherhood for Black women, including forced parenthood by slave masters who regarded them more as breeding stock than human mothers. Lyon Bennett selected direct quotes that clearly illustrate the unique complexities and nuances Black professional women face regarding motherhood. Chapter 4, Getting and Staying in the Mainstream: African American Women’s Contribution to the Human Sciences, is another collaboration between editors Jackson and Miller Arline. Analyzing the 37 women profiled in the 2009 book African American Women: Contributions to the Human Sciences (authors Miller, Mitstifer, and Vaughn), they coded each story to identify common themes. Even though all the women noted overt inequities in the education they were given compared to male and White peers, all highly valued education and self-efficacy. When they were unable to find professional mentors, they sought out their own mentors which allowed them to continue to be resilient. All women were passionately committed to the Home Economics discipline and their communities. Finally, all identified strong faith as a source of strength. Ethel G. Jones discusses the motivations and characteristics of Millennials (born 1980–1996) in Administrative Acumen in Working with Our Next Generation of Professionals. This information can help current experienced leaders understand generational differences in their mentees. BIPOC women can benefit from the health advice offered in The Effects of Trauma and Stress on Black Women’s Reproductive and Sexual Health by Holistic Reproductive Practitioner Quantanise M. Williams, MSW. Complementing chapter 3, Williams illustrates how intergenerational stress and trauma can alter genes and DNA, leading to increased risk factors for specific populations. Alice F. Joyner concludes Part I with a brief biography of an empowered Black woman in Chapter 7, Celebrating the Journey, an Extension of Legacy: Past, Present, Future A Biography of Dr. Alma Hobbs. Alma rose from rural Alabama to become the Deputy Assistant Secretary for the USDA; her influence is still seen in USDA, Extension, and 4-H programming today. Part II: Historically Black Colleges and Universities: Opportunities and Challenges presents a thematically cohesive discussion of the 1890 Land Grant Universities. Alice Joyner partnered with the late Dana D. Leggette-Traylor for Past, Present, and Future: An Exploratory of Transformation, Leadership, and the Contributions of the Home Economics Department at Virginia State University (VSU). They chronicle how home economics programming evolved to its present form as the Department of Family and Consumer Sciences (FCS). History of this nature is often lost; Joyner and Leggette-Traylor captured this journey succinctly for VSU. Dr. Whitaker Jr., Ahlishia J. Shipley, and Brenda A. Martin profile the status of Human Sciences educational programing in Responding to Twenty-First-Century Opportunities and Challenges: Family and Consumer Sciences Achievements and Impact at 1890 Land-Grant Institutions. Given the various terminologies used for our discipline (FCS, Human Sciences, Human Ecology, etc.) and differences in the structural schemas across organizations, this synthesis was no small feat. In chapter 10, The Value of AAFCS Accreditation at Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs). LaTonya L. Dixon and Cynthia M. Smith evaluated HCBU’s valuation of AAFCS accreditation. The conclusion brings up salient points about the challenges faced by HCBUs, including having less financial means and resources than predominantly White institutions. Part III: Internationalization and the Human Sciences includes chapters 11–13 and focuses on programs with outreach or education outside of the United States. Global Contributions of the Human Sciences, authored by Dr. Holland, Juanita Mendenhall, and Joanne Pearson, looks at a variety of international opportunities in which FCS programs have been involved, specifically highlighting those available at HBCUs. This exemplary collection would be a good start for any FCS professional considering international service opportunities. Progress and the Endless Battle: Injustices Against Women and Girls is a reprint of Dr. Miller Arline’s contribution to the International Federation for Home Economics (IFHE) March 2015 newsletter where she reflects on the 20th anniversary of the Beijing Platform for Action. Her commentary suggests that progress has been made for women’s rights globally since 1995, though more work remains to be done. Bettye P. Smith and Wenting Yang examine the effectiveness of study abroad educational experiences in Learning Outcomes in an Interdisciplinary Study Abroad Program: Developing a Global Perspective. Surveying students from the University of Georgia using Intercultural Learning Outcomes, most students demonstrated a higher global awareness after a study aboard program in Ghana. Chapters 14–17 comprise Part IV: Human Sciences Foundations for New Career Paths and looks at experiential learning experiences and career transitions. Amber N. Smith pens Young Children and Community Engagement: An Ecological Approach. Smith takes Urie Bronfenbrenner’s Ecological Systems Theory and uses it as a lens to examine the various facets of a community and the potential impacts it can have on a child and their future. Smith’s researched examples are valuable to anyone who interacts with a child. Penny A. Ralston recounts her career in retrospective in A Human Sciences Career in Transition: Continuity and Reinvention in Health Equity. Looking at the health disparities in north Florida, she envisioned the Center on Better Health and Life for Underserved Populations. She recounts difficulties in launching and securing funding while offering life lessons she learned to anyone contemplating, “Where do I go now?” In Family and Consumer Sciences in the Middle: Opportunities for Guiding Career Development, Dr. Holland evaluates if middle-school FCS curriculum can improve self-efficacy and career development in eighth-grade students. Though students see their FCS courses as having value, her results would indicate that FCS teachers have little or no effect on students’ career development. However, Holland notes that her sample was small and researching other groups may have different outcomes. Part IV concludes with Only One in the Room: Reflections on the Career of Shirley Hymon-Parker, Ph.D. Written with Kenneth Gruber, Hymon-Parker shares her story from humble beginnings on a sharecropper farm to Associate Dean for research at North Carolina Agricultural and Technical State University. Her story illustrates some of the themes identified in Chapter 2, as Hymon-Parker learned to trust her own voice, draw strength from her faith, and utilize family and outside mentors in order to achieve her goals. Part V Technology: Wave of the Present and Future includes two chapters and concludes this collection. Lacey J. Hillard, Danielle C. Stacey, AnneMarie McClain, Milena Batanova, and Richard M. Lerner author Media, Technology and the Family: Exploring the “CASIE” Model of Media Use in Youth Development. The CASIE model offers parents a positive framework to think about, model, and discuss social media use with their children. This model is widely applicable and of interest to professionals even beyond the field of Human Sciences. Evaluating positive uses of technology is also the focus of Technology Enhances Secondary Family and Consumer Sciences Instruction by Maggie A. Caples and Nadine Smith. Looking primarily at Baltimore County Public Schools, they discuss challenges and opportunities for enhanced integration of technology in the FCS classroom. They advise that school systems that develop a plan for rolling out technology that includes training teachers and staff will have the best outcomes. Though it might be hard to isolate a single theme under which to group all the chapters within African Americans in Human Sciences: Challenges and Opportunities, the pieces within are thought provoking and expose readers to multiple different perspectives. Those of us within FCS/Human Sciences know full well what it is to be so multifaceted as to defy a solitary theme or description. As a teacher-educator I can think of multiple places to share each of the chapters across my vast network of students, colleagues, and peers; my hope is that this review can act as a guide for specific interest groups. Administrators in Higher Education should read Chapter 2, Chapter 4, and all of Part II. Likewise, I recommend Part II to those who have interest in the history of Career and Technical Education. Given the innovative and unique ways in which we operate, I believe my fellow Human Scientists would also find these readings accessible and applicable to the variety of topics they engage with personally and professionally. I applaud editors Jackson, Holland, and Miller Arline for putting this collection together and hope this is the start of a trend where scholarship from diverse viewpoints continues to be disseminated and discussed.
Language: English
Open Access status: hybrid
Estimated APC paid: $2,550
OpenAlex ID: W4213064101
Cites:
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10