Work

Editorial

Year: 2000
Type: editorial
Abstract: All the articles in this issue of Health Expectations (including the book reviews) are about communication. Each of the studies used qualitative methods to gain an in-depth understanding of users’ views and in all cases the authors have stressed the need for improved understanding of the user’s perspective and the context in which care is delivered. Two papers look at the communication needs of parents of young children. Hoddinott and Pill1 found that women trying to acquire breast-feeding skills preferred non-directive apprenticeship-style learning, rather than a prescriptive approach. Similarly, the parents in Houston and Pickering’s study2 who made out-of-hours calls were seeking information and the skills to help their sick children themselves rather than trying to avoid their responsibilities. Health professionals need to learn the subtle art of skills transfer instead of telling people what to do or doing it for them. The theme of understanding lay expectations and their potential conflict with professional perspectives is reiterated in the other papers in this issue. Gray and co-workers3 show that more than good intentions are required if researchers are to succeed in encouraging consumer participation in research while avoiding an adverse effect on participants or on the research product. The study by Beaulieu and co-workers4 demonstrates that there is no obvious technical fix which will ensure that prevention guidelines are implemented. Consumers were more positive than providers about the potential value of computerised evidence-based information, but introducing these systems without taking account of the context in which they are to be used and users’ attitudes to the information they contain will not solve the problems. The study by Parsons and co-workers5 looks at attitudes to risk and uncertainty among clinicians and women undergoing genetic assessment for breast cancer. The clinicians stressed the uncertainties inherent in genetic assessment, but the women nevertheless seemed to find the reassurance they were seeking. The findings raise the question of whether lay beliefs in the value of screening and surveillance can or should be accommodated in the face of conflicting calls on resources.
Language: Spanish
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4214683363
Cites: 5
Cited by:
Related to: 10