Year: 2022
Type: editorial
Abstract: This issue begins with a transcribed speech given by Hans Bruyninckx Executive Director of the European Environment Agency (EEA) to the European Evaluation Society's online conference held in October 2021.We have published many articles now on the challenges for evaluators as a result of the environmental, sustainability and climate-related crises humanity faces.A call by the Executive Director of the EEA for the evaluation community to make 'impactful contributions in times of urgency' reinforces the strong message of this stream of articles, including the collective reflections of many leading evaluators following COP 26 published in issue 28 (1).More hopefully, Bruyninckx also highlights some of the practical actions that the European Union (EU) policymakers are planning and discussing -and even starting to implement -within the framework of the European Green Deal.The war in Ukraine gives these thoughts about the need for systemic change and for just transitions towards sustainability added urgency.Cobi Calyx and Summer May Finlay propose extending a recently developed 'open' framework to evaluate 'participatory' and 'citizen' science in ways that acknowledge Indigenous rights and IDS (indigenous data sovereignty).The last 20 years have seen a progression from 'scientific citizenship' that emphasises democratic and informed consent to government science policies; to 'citizen science' that emphasises citizen co-determination of the scientific agenda and co-production of scientific knowledge.Over the last decade, attention has focused increasingly on how citizen science can promote equity and justice rather than reinforce wellunderstood structural inequalities.Many of the authors' arguments resonate with debates about the ethical responsibilities of evaluators advanced by Schwandt 24(3); and Chouinard and Cousins 27(3).Calyx and Finlay take us to the frontline of contemporary struggles to 'decolonise' science and ensure inclusivity in the formulation, production and use of knowledge.The authors' positioning is from 'the continent now known as Australia' and from an explicitly non-European standpoint.They are concerned that an otherwise useful evaluation framework proposed by Kieslinger and colleagues in 2018 'risks perpetuating neo-colonialism through limiting acceptance of different forms of knowledge'.The authors argue that the proposed 'open' framework to evaluate citizen science does not take account of 'broader structural forces'.Calyx and Finlay are primarily concerned with reconciling an 'open' evaluation framework with Indigenous rights, and advocate adopting a decolonising approach.However, they argue that such an approach is not confined to Indigenous communities, but are of 'global relevance', for example, for 'marginalised populations such as migrants, refugees and/or gender diverse populations'.1098262E VI0010.
Source: Evaluation
Author: Elliot Stern
Language: Spanish
Subfield: Public Administration
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4229061192
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to:
