Work

Assembly and Motility of Eukaryotic Cilia and Flagella. Lessons from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

Year: 2001
Type: article
Abstract: Cilia and flagella are among the most ancient cellular organelles, providing motility for primitive eukaryotic cells living in an aqueous environment. During adaptation to life on land, some groups of organisms, including advanced fungi, red algae, cellular slime molds, conifers, and angiosperms, lost the ability to assemble flagella (Raven et al., 1999). The centriole or basal body, which organizes the assembly of flagella, also is absent in these groups. In other lineages, flagella were retained only on gametic cells. Land plants are believed to have arisen from one group of green algae, the charophytes (for review, see Bhattacharya and Medlin, 1998;Qiu and Palmer, 1999), in which the only flagellated cells are motile sperm. The first land plants, bryophytes, which are thought to be the ancestors of higher plants, also produce flagellated sperm cells that require water to swim to the egg. Ultrastructural features of the basal body apparatus in the flagellated cells have provided important morphological data for phylogenetic studies of algae and bryophytes. The absence of centrioles and flagella in all but sperm cells also characterizes seedless vascular plants (pteridophytes) including ferns and the genus Equisetum (Raven et al., 1999). Water is required for these sperm to swim to the archegonium containing the egg. A further adaptation for colonization on land developed in gymnosperm phyla represented by cycads and gingko. These plants produce pollen grains that are transferred to the vicinity of the female gametophyte. A pollen tube extends toward the archegonium and bursts to release flagellated sperm that swim through the released fluid to fertilize the egg. Sperm in seedless vascular plants, cycads, and gingko are large (up to 300 μm in diameter), spectacularly complex cells that swim with hundreds to thousands of flagella. The de novo synthesis of the centrioles during the formation and differentiation of these sperm cells was documented a century ago, but fascinating questions remain about the developmental mechanisms for these events (see, for example, Hart and Wolniak, 1998). How do flagella of plants and animals differ? The main evolutionary difference is that in animals, flagella acquired new functions as multicellular forms evolved. For example, in mammals, epithelial cells in the respiratory system, the female reproductive system, and in the ventricles of the brain differentiate to produce multiple cilia that beat coordinately to propel fluids over the tissues. Most types of mammalian cells express a primary cilium whose growth is nucleated by the older of the two centrioles in a cell. These organelles have been shown to play crucial roles in embryo development (for review, seeSchneider and Brueckner, 2000). Modified primary cilia play important roles in the function of sensory cells such as photoreceptor cells (for review, see Rosenbaum et al., 1999). C. reinhardtii flagella. A, A longitudinal section through the basal bodies and flagella of C. reinhardtii. CW, Cell wall; PM, plasma membrane; OD, outer doublet microtubule of the axoneme; CP, central pair microtubules; BB, basal body; DF, distal striated fiber; TZ, transition zone; PF, proximal fiber connecting the two basal bodies. Electron micrograph by Dr. William Dentler (adapted from Trends in Cell Biology, Vol 1, No. 6, 1991, with copyright permission from Elsevier Science). B, Scanning electron micrograph of a C. reinhardtii cell. Image provided by Dr. William Dentler. All plants need to optimize their exposure to light by growing toward it, as land plants do, or by swimming toward it, as flagellated organisms do. C. reinhardtii cells swim to optimal light levels by regulating flagellar beating in the process of phototaxis. The two anterior flagella, 12 μm in length, propel the cell forward by beating in opposite directions with an asymmetric ciliary waveform (something like a breast stroke) with a frequency of approximately 60 beats s−1. Light is sensed by a rhodopsin-like photoreceptor located in the eyespot on the side of the cell (for review, see Hegemann, 1997; Sineshchekov and Govorunova, 1999). During phototactic behavior, light intensity in the environment is surveyed as the cells swim in a helical path, rotating around their longitudinal axis. A photoreceptor current is generated across the plasma membrane at the eyespot; signal transduction involves changes in the intraflagellar free Ca2+ concentration. The two flagella, denoted by their positions cis or trans to the eyespot, show a differential response in beating to changes in submicromolar calcium levels, allowing the cell to change swimming direction (for review, seeMitchell, 2000). Mutations that affect phototactic behavior are being analyzed to define the molecular mechanisms in the signal transduction pathways (Hegemann, 1997). Although C. reinhardtii cells need light for photosynthesis, too much light can damage the chloroplast. When cells are exposed to a large increase in light intensity, they undergo a photoshock response characterized by a remarkable change in flagellar waveform (Sineshchekov and Govorunova, 1999). The flagella stop beating and then beat with a symmetric flagellar waveform (resembling a sinusoidal pattern) to move the cell briefly backward. The shift from ciliary “breast stroke” to flagellar “flutter kick” beating is thought to be controlled by activation of voltage-gated Ca2+ channels in the flagellar membrane. The resulting transient burst of intraflagellar free Ca2+ signals the change in flagellar beating mode. C. reinhardtii flagella also play an important role during sexual reproduction. When starved for nitrogen, vegetative cells differentiate into gametes of mating type plus or mating type minus, a process controlled by the mating type locus (for review, see Goodenough et al., 1995). This process includes expression of Hyp-rich glycoproteins known as flagellar agglutinins on the flagellar surfaces, allowing gametes of opposite mating type to recognize and adhere to one another (for review, see Adair, 1985). Simple flagellar contact is enough to trigger an increase in cAMP levels, inducing downstream signaling pathways that lead to cell fusion (for review, see Pan and Snell, 2000). Schematic diagram of the flagellar axoneme in cross-section. Mutations in C. reinhardtii that affect the assembly or function of specific structures are indicated. (Reproduced from Porter and Sale [2000] by copyright permission of the Rockefeller University Press). C. reinhardtii is the only system in which transformation of nuclear, chloroplast, and mitochondrial genomes has been achieved (Harris, 2001). The nuclear genome may be transformed using various methods, including particle bombardment, agitation with glass beads, or electroporation. Transformation of plasmid DNA into the nucleus results in random, nonhomologous integration events, whereas transformation of the chloroplast genome occurs exclusively by homologous recombination. Tagging of genes by insertional mutagenesis and subsequent analysis of genomic DNA flanking the inserted plasmid has been a fruitful approach for identifying and cloning genes encoding components of flagella and the basal body apparatus. These mutations are generally null mutations due to the deletions that accompany plasmid insertion. Wild-type genes or altered genes can be transformed into these null mutants for phenotype testing. In a reverse genetic approach, banks of insertional mutant strains with motility defects have been screened for mutations in specific genes by hybridizing blots of genomic DNA to sequences of interest. A hybridizing restriction fragment present in DNA from wild-type cells but absent or altered in size in DNA from a mutant strain indicates that the mutant strain may carry an insertional mutation in the gene of interest (for review, see Pazour and Witman, 2000). Despite the importance of the insertional mutagenesis approach, the phenotype of a null mutation is not usually as informative as the phenotypes of more subtle mutations in the same gene. Further, null mutations in some genes of interest may have a lethal phenotype. In addition, because hundreds of mutants with interesting phenotypes are already on the genetic map, map-based cloning of genes identified by mutation will be important for future progress. To this end, a molecular map coaligned with the genetic map of the C. reinhardtii genome has been developed (Silflow, 1998). This map contains nearly 300 molecular markers, including RFLP and single nucleotide polymorphism markers, with an average spacing of four genetic map units. As new sequences are placed on the molecular map, their possible linkage to specific mutations on the genetic map can be assessed. Molecular markers on each linkage group also facilitate the genetic mapping of new mutations. The molecular map has served as the basis for developing a physical map of the genome based on overlapping contigs of bacterial artificial chromosome clones aligned with the genetic and molecular map. The physical map has recently been used for map-based cloning of genes involved in flagellar function in our laboratories. The structure and mechanism of motility of C. reinhardtii flagella are representative of “9 + 2” motile cilia and flagella in diverse eukaryotic systems (Figs. 1A and 2). Nine doublet microtubules, each composed of a complete A tubule (13 protofilaments) fused to a partial (11 protofilaments) B tubule, form an elongated cylinder growing from the A and B tubules of the triplet microtubules that form the wall of the basal body. A specialized region of the plasma membrane extends to cover the bundle of microtubules and associated proteins, termed the axoneme. At the base of the axoneme is a specialized structure called the transition zone that is involved in flagellar excision, among other possible functions. When flagella are excised in response to lowered pH or other stimuli, doublet microtubules are cleaved just distal to the transition zone, and the plasma membrane seals the resulting gap. Katanin, a microtubule-severing protein, localizes to the region of the transition zone (for review, see Quarmby and Lohret, 1999). Two central pair microtubules begin just above the transition zone, and extend the length of the axoneme in the center of the ring of doublet microtubules. A combination of genetic and biochemical approaches has unraveled the protein composition and functions of structures within the axoneme. Ultrastructural analysis of mutant strains has revealed missing or altered structures that result in specific motility defects. Comparison of axonemal proteins from the mutant cells with those from wild-type cells has identified proteins missing in the mutant that may be components of the missing structure (for review, see Dutcher, 2000). Gamete fusion results in quadriflagellate, temporary dikaryons that are useful for in situ complementation tests. In dikaryons derived from mating mutant cells with wild-type cells, defective proteins in flagella of mutant cells may be rescued by proteins from the wild-type cells, resulting in four flagella with wild-type motility. Another powerful approach for studying the mechanisms of flagellar beating is the in vitro reactivation of axoneme beating or outer doublet sliding in the presence of MgATP. These in vitro assays using axonemes from mutant and wild-type strains and using drugs to inhibit the activity of specific enzymes have provided insight into the regulation of flagellar dynein activity (for review, see Porter and Sale, 2000). How do flagella move? Flagellar beating is driven by flagellar dyneins, molecular motor proteins that bind the A tubule of each outer doublet as cargo. In the presence of ATP, the dyneins bind the B tubule of the adjacent outer doublet and move along the B tubule toward its minus end, resulting in sliding between pairs of outer doublets. Interdoublet sliding is constrained by doublet attachment to the basal body and by structural links between the doublets, resulting in flagellar bending. The dyneins are arranged in two macromolecular complexes called arms that are different in function and composition (for review, see King, 2000; Mitchell, 2000; Porter and Sale, 2000). The inner arm dyneins, located closest to the central pair microtubules, are remarkably complex. Seven distinct isoforms have been resolved biochemically. These contain 11 heavy chains of >400 kD, together with numerous intermediate and light chains. The inner arm components are arranged along the A tubule with a 96-nm longitudinal repeat pattern that has been analyzed using computer averaging of electron micrographs from sections of axonemes (for review, see Porter and Sale, 2000). Among the protein components of the inner arm dynein are actin and the calcium-binding protein, centrin. Mutations in genes encoding inner arm dynein components result in changes in the waveform rather than beat frequency. The ida5 mutation contains a defect in the unique gene encoding conventional actin. The phenotype of this mutation, the loss of several species of inner-arm dyneins, indicates that actin is required for assembly of these motor protein complexes. Remarkably, when rabbit muscle skeletal actin labeled with a fluorescent tag was introduced into ida5 mutant cells by electroporation, a significant fraction of the cells recovered motility and incorporated the fluorescent actin into the axoneme (Hayashi et al., 2001). This result suggests new opportunities for introducing proteins and other molecules into C. reinhardtii cells and for determining the role of actin in inner arm dynein assembly. The outer arm dyneins, which are spaced along the axoneme with a 24-nm period, contain a single isoform with three catalytic heavy chains, two intermediate chains, and eight light chains. Mutations that affect outer dynein arm components generally reduce beat frequency. The intermediate and light chains appear to play roles in regulating dynein activity and in binding dynein to its cargo. A docking complex containing three subunits is essential for assembly of the outer arm dyneins the A The flagellar in living cells require of dynein activity around the and along the length of the axoneme. within the such as by the of the outer dynein arm on the microtubule doublet termed may of dynein function and Witman, The two flagella are with each such that the flagella beat with in opposite has a role for the central pair apparatus and the in dynein arm The from the B tubule of each with a pair of within each 96-nm longitudinal repeat 2). The appear to with from the central pair microtubules. Mutations that lead to complete or partial loss of the result in flagella. The contain at proteins, of which are located in the structure (for review, see Mitchell, 2000; Porter and Sale, 2000). The protein by the was recently shown to be an protein, which localizes protein A by binding the is at the base of the the inner dynein the protein A in a to the activity of these motor proteins et al., 2001). and the dynein light were to be associated with the that a role in calcium of flagellar beating by the et al., 2001). The central pair apparatus of the and microtubules and a of that appear to with (for review, see and 1997; Mitchell, 2000). The central pair during the beat in C. reinhardtii and some other has been that the rotating central pair function like a to of and dynein arms et al., 1999). mutations in genes encoding components of the central pair apparatus have cloning of several of these central pair components have flagella. mutations motility to the and central pair mutants the missing The mutations genes encoding outer arm dynein heavy chains, inner dynein arm or components of the dynein a of proteins located within the inner arm 96-nm repeat (for review, see Porter and Sale, 2000). of motility by the mutations suggests that they components of a system that dynein Schematic diagram of the basal body apparatus reinhardtii as from the positions of triplet microtubules that form the of the basal bodies. indicates the of the protein at the distal of each basal body. and microtubule DF, striated fiber; PF, proximal associated with the the positions of bodies. from and with copyright permission of the Rockefeller University Press). In with centriole in cells, the primary of basal body in C. reinhardtii is (for review, see et al., 2000). basal body to a single body, at a specific the proximal of the At the pair to a cell that contains two basal bodies in by at one cell The of a body has structural and For example, in cells, only the older centriole is of the growth of a primary In some cells, the of each on the of the basal body from which more than one cell is required for a basal body to a known as flagellar transformation et al., In C. the two basal bodies are in a with the basal body located in a with to the subtle in motility the flagella by the two basal bodies 2000). C. reinhardtii a unique to the fascinating process of basal body because of a of mutations. with to assemble flagella on the basal body, resulting in cells with a single trans to the eyespot (for review, see et al., 2000). The gene identified by mutation was to a new of the (for review, see Dutcher, 2001). bodies in mutant cells are defective in the assembly of the of the triplet a role for in these specialized microtubules. of the of the basal body cylinder suggests that has on to be a of basal bodies and centrioles (for review, see and 1999). The importance of these asymmetric for the and function of the basal body apparatus has been by genetic and biochemical studies of C. reinhardtii and the review, see et al., 2000). distinct structures with specific microtubule of the basal bodies The distal fiber to triplet microtubules 1, and of each basal body, resulting in the of the two basal and the two flagella from in and Witman, The distal fiber contains a calcium-binding protein that is also a of the flagellar transition also bind to microtubule and of each basal body and extend toward the providing a between these is also a of the flagellar transition to these which play a role in of the of basal of basal bodies to cells, and flagellar excision, as shown by the phenotype of mutations in the gene encoding centrin. is the molecular basis of and is important for basal body The cloning of the in C. reinhardtii has revealed a molecular for the to the basal bodies. et al., 2001). Mutations in this gene result in cell with a of flagella and in defective basal body The gene localizes within the basal body at its distal end, with a asymmetric triplet microtubule on the The of the distal striated fiber to the same side of the basal body suggests that the protein may be involved in connecting the distal fiber to the basal bodies to their in the cell and during the cell The regulation of flagellar assembly may be at as complex as the regulation of flagellar beating (for review, see and 1998). For example, when one of the two flagella is the other one to into the the for the to At some the two flagella the same length, at which the and flagella to length with is that the cell is to two flagella of The of flagella is by results from in that significant of proteins occurs in flagella and 2001). with or flagella that the length to which flagella assemble is controlled by the of a large of gene flagella mutants flagella of to of length flagella mutants can flagella to three length (up to or of these mutant cells swim mutants show behavior in the When mutants with flagella are to wild-type cells, the flagella to wild-type When mutants with flagella are to wild-type cells, the flagella to wild-type length within Most in do the flagella average the length of the four flagella of the cell. the wild-type length is on the mutant flagella. These results that cells are to the length of their flagella and that length at a for intraflagellar of toward the microtubule plus at the flagellar is on toward the base of the minus dynein from Pazour et by copyright permission of the Rockefeller University Press). possible role for is to carry flagellar proteins to the distal of the growing which is the of assembly of flagellar To of the proteins that the has been shown to be an axonemal structural The of the proteins with the is too to and or the of the some other role in the flagella. is for example, that the of the of a signaling mechanism used to the of the flagella. show that the of the is essential for and C. et al., 2001). Mutations in the gene encoding the a lead to a phenotype (for review, see Rosenbaum et al., 1999). the mutation is has been possible to show that is to and to assemble the flagella because mutants at the their flagella. Mutations in the a of the dynein also defective mutants with defects a about of the flagellar This is with possible of this phenotype is that particle is required to the motor and associated proteins to the cell body to motility to dynein may also play a role in the by flagellar proteins to the base of the in for assembly. is interesting that dynein has been in and have of dynein genes from higher genomes et al., 2001). proteins are in animals as analysis has shown that they are involved in the assembly and of cilia in A of mutants in the with defects in the assembly of a of sensory cilia have been shown to affect proteins with in C. reinhardtii genes (for review, see Rosenbaum et al., 1999). These proteins may also play a role in Mutations in the gene in and defects in the assembly of primary cilia in cells, resulting in This gene is homologous to a C. reinhardtii gene et al., 2000). have the importance of eukaryotic not only in but also in development and in sensory The of C. reinhardtii together with the molecular have placed this system in a unique to into molecular mechanisms for the assembly and function of these The of flagella, and basal bodies for systems extends those that produce flagellated For example, of the remarkable de novo assembly of hundreds of proteins to form these organelles may of that will be in and that the organelles in proteins in flagella and basal bodies have been including proteins and molecular motor Comparison of the functions of these proteins in cells centrioles and in cells that centrioles as basal bodies will into the of cells and The provided by William Sale, and and for in of are to the of our for
Authors: Carolyn D. Silflow, Paul A. Lefebvre
Language: English
Subfield: Genetics
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W4230738141
FWCI: 3.825
Cites: 40
Cited by: 249
Related to: 9