Year: 2013
Type: editorial
Abstract: This issue begins with a viewpoint article reviewing the most recent and dramatic change in patient and public involvement in England.1 These changes are a part of the most significant reform of the English NHS since it was founded in 1948. The body of the issue starts with two review articles that synthesize the current state of knowledge. The potential impact of stigma on interactions between obese patients and health professionals is the focus of a systematic review conducted by Mold and Forbes.2 The synthesis of the findings of the 30 studies identified from the initial 278 screened papers suggests that obesity stigmatizes patients and leads to feelings of powerlessness that creates inequity in treatment choices. Georgy and colleagues review the existing theoretical frameworks for understanding of doctors' and patients' expectations in relation to pain management in primary care.3 Adopting an integrative literature review approach, they present a new conceptual model, the Met-Matched model. They argue that this model by matching both General Practitioners' and patients' expectations can improve the quality of back pain consultations in primary care and respond to the frustrations of physicians when dealing with back pain. The next article by Kim, Blendon and Benson explores the challenges for health-care reform in Latin American countries using data from 19 212 adults interviewed face-to-face in the 2007 LatinobarĂ³metro survey in 17 Latin American.4 Accounts of people's satisfaction and experience of health care varied within and across countries with respondents in seven countries being dissatisfied. Problems with access to health care and the presence of democracy were much more powerful explanatory variables than per capita spending on health care. These findings provide challenges for tailoring health reform in Latin America. The lack of agreement between psychiatrists and patients on the goals of treatment has been seen as a significant barrier to success. Using structured interviews face-to-face with 105 outpatients diagnosed with schizophrenia and on the phone with 160 psychiatrists in Germany, Bridges and colleagues explored the nature of concordance in treatment.5 Patient respondents tended to value practical treatment goals more than psychiatrists. Without recognition of this distinction, the potential of shared decision making is heavily compromised. Decision making was also at the heart of Dieng and colleagues' study of cervical screening in Australian, using data from a structured telephone questionnaire with a random sample of Australian women.6 Not only do women want more frequent screening and secondary prevention of cervical cancer they want more information prior to a pap smear and more active participation in decisions about screening and follow-up. Exploring the tension between shared decision making and evidence-based care in diabetes is the focus of the next article by Shortus et al.7 Drawing on data from in-depth interviews with a range of different Australian providers (19 General Practitioners, eight Allied Health Professionals and two endocrinologists), they identify the active management of patient involvement in decision making. However, the aim of the involvement differed with some managing involvement to achieve ideal biomedical outcomes, an evidence-based medicine approach, while others adopted a personalized health-care approach and prioritized patient preferences. Increasingly, concerns about long-term conditions and risk have focused on behavioural change, and Liau and colleagues report the readiness of Malaysian participant to make changes in diet and lifestyle.8 Drawing on cross-sectional survey date from 144 employees of Universiti Sains Malaysia, they highlight both the level of physical activity and consumption of fruit and vegetables as two specific risk factors associated with an increased chance of long-term conditions. While men tended to be more active than women, the findings have implications for public health policy in Malaysia. The final article considers the importance of involving the public rather than patients in decisions about the governance of medical data. Molster and colleagues describe a four-day deliberative public forum sponsored by the Office of Population Health Genomics in Western Australia.9 Citizens deliberating in small groups were able to make decisions about complex issues that can inform the trade-offs embedded in policy making. As important, the public availability of the materials and how they are translated to policy should prompt further citizen deliberation and increase the validity and acceptability of the resulting policies. Taken together, the articles in this issue illustrate the international nature of Health Expectations and the relevance and importance of both patient and public involvement in health care and health policy. Authors from Australia, Malaysia, Germany, Latin America and Britain share their data, analysis and interpretation to disseminate an understanding of particular substantive issues but also methods as a part of a movement to shift the culture of health-care practice and government policy that regulates and shapes those practices. Indeed, as a whole, these articles present a challenge to health-care professionals of the need to take account of patient preferences as a form of evidence as a part of shared decision making. But involvement is not only about patients, if we want policies that support an active role for those who use health service, then policy makers too must involve the public in their work.
Source: Health Expectations
DOI: 10.1111/hex.12072
Author: Jonathan Tritter
Institution: University of Warwick
Language: Spanish
Subfield: Family Practice
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4231124411
