Year: 1994
Type: letter
Abstract: Editor's note: The above letter was referred to the authors of the original letter, and their reply follows. Dr. Gordon suggests 2 strategies for nursing homes to employ when utilizating CPR in nursing home residents. He notes that the goal to be achieved is “not subjecting frail, institutionalized elders to futile CPR attempts.” The data from our study suggest that physicians exercise great selectivity in performing CPR in nursing home residents. Among all nursing home deaths over a 4-year period, only 2% were associated with CPR utilization.1 Other studies have shown comparably low rates of utilization.2 In our study, the utilization of “911” for emergency transfers was, in fact, the way that the nursing home residents were managed. The availability of Advanced Cardiac Life Support trained staff in a long-term care facility, as described by Gordon,3 did not occur among the institutions we reviewed, and we suspect this would be unusual among nursing homes in the United States. Regarding the futility of CPR among these frail elders, there remains the issue of the definition of futility. Among our patients receiving CPR, there was 5% survival. The subgroups where arrests were witnessed and who had ventricular fibrillation had a 27% survival.4 This latter outcome would be comparable to results achieved in out-of-hospital cardiac arrests in the elderly. We would agree with Gordon that our data suggest that outcomes are poor among nursing home residents who have unwitnessed arrests and rhythms other than ventricular fibrillation. Functional status or diagnosis could not predict outcome among our residents who underwent CPR.4 Nursing home policies to initiate CPR for witnessed arrests and continue CPR in those residents with ventricular fibrillation/tachycardia on their initial electrocardiogram seem reasonable. Beyond this it would seem difficult to establish criteria for nurses to withhold the use of CPR among nursing home patients beyond what is already occurring. Finally, our data do not address the issue of Do Not Attempt Resuscitation (DNAR) order as a “default” position for long-term care facilities. By “default” I assume Dr. Gordon means that as a rule, residents receive a DNR order unless the patient/physician specifically requests exemption. We did find a sizable proportion of nursing homes (39%) that had no residents undergo CPR over a 4-year period.1 Homes that were nonprofit and that had a high number of deaths per bed were less likely to employ CPR among their residents.
Authors: E. Duthie, S. Kartes, D. Tresch
Institution: Medical College of Wisconsin
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4231398553
