Work

Reply

Year: 2021
Type: letter
Abstract: We thank Drs Moradi, Naybandi Atashi, Kazemi and Rahmani for their appreciation of our manuscript regarding the additional value of fetal neurosonography and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in a population of fetuses at risk for acquired brain anomalies1. We gladly accept the opportunity to respond to the three issues they raise. Firstly, we want to clarify that we did not intend to deny the usefulness of fetal MRI. Nevertheless, based on our study results, we put emphasis on the performance of multiplanar neurosonography in a population at risk for acquired anomalies. Low-grade peri- or intraventricular hemorrhage (IVH) was encountered more often on neurosonography than on axial ultrasound and MRI. It is difficult to interpret the results of publications on this subject (including some cited by Moradi et al.2, 3 and another which we would like to add4) because, often, fetal ultrasound examinations consisting of axial planes only are compared to multiplanar MRI examinations, which we (as well as others5) believe is ‘comparing apples and oranges’. In that respect, we absolutely agree with Di Mascio et al.6, emphasizing the need for detailed neurosonography performed by an expert when fetal brain anomalies are suspected. We also endorse their message that the additional value of fetal MRI appears to be much lower than suggested previously based on studies comparing axial ultrasound planes to multiplanar MRI; overall, in cases of ventriculomegaly, MRI detected 1.1% more cases of IVH than did multiplanar neurosonography6. This finding was, as a matter of fact, not confirmed in our study, in which (low-grade) IVH was seen on nine neurosonographic examinations as compared to one fetal MRI examination (although not necessarily related to ventriculomegaly)1. This difference might be explained by the fact that half of the studies included in the systematic review that used multiplanar fetal neurosonography reported a transabdominal approach or did not state which approach was used (or whether in fact multiple planes were obtained7). Our multicenter study was actually set up to evaluate the additional value of detailed neurosonography and MRI, as proposed in, amongst others, the publication by Di Mascio et al.6. When addressing the limitations of our study, we noted that a stronger relationship between neurosonography and MRI might be present when using new magnetic resonance techniques (or 3-Tesla MRI). Secondly, Moradi et al. are absolutely right that the image shown in figure 2e is a T2- (and not a T1-) weighted sequence. We apologize for this error. The image that is shown, however, does belong to the described fetus/neonate. In a consensus meeting, the experts assessed the entire MRI examination and concluded that the signal intensity of the white matter was mildly increased. Regarding the third comment, we would like to reflect on the statement that, in figure 2 in our manuscript, no evolutionary changes were encountered between prenatal and neonatal neurosonography. We would like to note that there were in fact evolutionary changes on brain imaging for this (and other) fetus(es) during the course of the study. For the purpose of our study, we were unable to go into detail for individual cases; however, in the supplementary material (table S3) of the study, we provided more detailed information on the findings during the multiple brain imaging examinations that were performed. Here, we elucidate the importance of serial multiplanar neurosonography by presenting the individual trajectory of brain ultrasound findings for the fetus in figure 2. The first fetal neurosonographic examination, at 28 + 4 weeks' gestation, showed no periventricular echogenicity (PVE) changes, and Grade-I–II IVH with mild ventricular dilatation (10–12 mm) on the left side. At 30 + 4 weeks, Grade-IA PVE changes in the left frontal and occipital areas were seen, as well as Grade-II IVH on the left side, with asymmetrical lateral ventricles (left larger than right) and an irregular, thickened ventricular wall on the left side. The subsequent two fetal neurosonographic examinations were of insufficient quality (at 33 + 5 weeks, the right side was normal and the left side was insufficient for assessment; at 35 + 5 weeks, the quality was insufficient for both sides). The first neonatal cranial ultrasound examination, < 24 h after birth (at 37 + 5 weeks) showed Grade-IA PVE changes on both sides in the frontal lobes, and Grade-II IVH on the left side. Ventriculomegaly was not present. Considering the time between the examinations on which IVH was seen before (28 + 4 weeks) and after birth (37 + 5 weeks), the origin of the intraventricular echogenicity on the first neonatal ultrasound may be a remnant of the prenatally acquired bleeding, but a new IVH in the same region cannot be ruled out. Both the second cranial ultrasound examination and neonatal MRI, performed approximately 6 weeks after birth, showed no anomalies. This underlines that the evolution of low-grade acquired brain anomalies detected before birth is not necessarily equal to the pathway described in the article by Parodi et al., who refer to ultrasound findings in neonatal studies from quite a while ago8. This emphasizes the need for follow-up studies initiated prenatally and repeated postnatally, with similar multiplanar neurosonography, and, when applicable, MRI facilities and skills. The fact that (mild) acquired anomalies are visible on brain imaging before birth, but are not progressive or even no longer visible at a later stage, has been reported previously in fetal studies using serial neurosonography in populations at risk for developing brain damage (those with preterm birth or hypertensive disorders)9, 10. In these studies, an association was seen between persistent and/or progressive echogenicity changes after birth and adverse neurodevelopmental outcome in childhood11.
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4232166167
Cites: 11
Cited by:
Related to: 10