Work

In reply

Year: 1991
Type: letter
Abstract: Editors note:—The utility of augmentation with thyroid hormone is highly controversial, with the weight of evidence being against a significant beneficial effect. The above letter was referred to the author of the initial paper and Dr. Lee's reply follows. In reply:—Drs. Zimmer and Price argue that an adequate trial of therapy for depression would include systematic attempts to achieve a therapeutic response to antidepressant medication and, if necessary, electroconvulsive therapy. As stated earlier,1 I agree that depression should be aggressively treated in older persons. That may include ECT in many older patients who cannot tolerate or do not improve with antidepressant medications. I would argue, however, that if the patient is incapacitated, the decision to use ECT is subject to the same standards that guide proxy decision-making for other forms of life-sustaining therapy. That is, if the patient had expressed a preference not to receive ECT prior to becoming incapacitated, that desire should be respected. On the other hand, if the patient's preferences regarding ECT are unknown, then the proxy decision-maker must weigh the expected benefits of ECT against the burden of treatment for that patient. In the case I presented for discussion, neither the psychiatric consultants nor the non-psychiatric physicians believed that the patient had received an adequate trial of medication for depression. However, ECT was considered risky in view of his precarious medical condition. His poor prognosis for recovery from renal failure, his diminishing independence, and the inevitability of nursing home placement, an outcome which was unacceptable to him, all raised significant questions about the burden of continued invasive treatments for this patient whose quality of life, if he survived, would be exceedingly poor. Moreover, if guardianship had been obtained, his wife would have been appointed proxy decisionmaker. At the time that ECT was considered seriously, she and her son were strong in their belief that the patient's refusals of treatment were authentic. What this discussion points up is the need for empiric research which further characterizes how depression affects the capacity to make decisions involving life-sustaining therapy. We are actively investigating this question at our institution. Better information with which to define the appropriate boundaries of patient autonomy and beneficent paternalism for depressed, older persons will enlighten decisions about ECT and other forms of invasive therapy in the face of treatment refusal.
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4232378838
Cites: 1
Cited by:
Related to: 10