Work

Editorial

Year: 2015
Type: editorial
Abstract: The first of this issue's papers has been much trailed by our publisher.Taylor & Francis is very ready to promote papers considered to be of wide public interest.The paper by Sotaro Shibayama and Yasunori Baba, from the University of Tokyo, qualifies in that it adds to understanding of a major problem in academic life.Shibayama and Baba look at how academic authors respond to the comments of journal referees.Their response is very likely to determine whether their papers are published.Publishing in top journals has become a key measureoften the key measureof academic performance.On this single performance measure the reputation and funding of institutions, and the career prospects of individuals are in large part dependent.Such dependence provides ample incentive for gaming and the participants in academic publishing (editors, authors, publishers, and the institutions that support them) have corrupted a vulnerable system to their advantage.Top journals must publish papers that boost their journal impact factors (which are what makes them top journals).Because the impact factors are calculated from the frequency with which a journal's papers are cited, top journals crave papers that are readily cited.The most citable papers (those that cite papers that everyone else cites, that agree with as much as possible and avoid the negative, the new and the contentious) are the most valued papers.Research can be hard to publish.Complaints about the social costs of this system would be overwhelming were it not buttressed by that guarantee of academic quality, peer review.Those with a vested interest in academic publishing are particularly anxious to believe that referees ensure only the best papers are published in the best journals.Shibayama and Baba are less impressed by peer review.In fact, they find peer review to be part of the problem.Their surveys show Japanese scientists to be so desperate to publish that they will make any changes their referees require, no matter how wrong they know the changes to be.Shibayama and Baba are categorical in calling this behaviour 'dishonest': authors themselves may see their behaviour as simply pragmatic, convinced that failure to oblige a referee in every possible way is to court rejection.The publish or perish predicament has had such an overwhelming influence on intellectual life that many academics have forgotten an older injunction to publish and be damned.Academics are now so anxious to avoid perishing in this life that they risk damnation in the next.A Faustian pact binds those who write papers to be counted rather than read, who have little to say, but need to say it in top journals.Shibayama and Baba find that, in their willingness to be dishonest in order to be published, academics have taken one more step along the road to perdition.The race to publish is also an aspect of the paper by Kyriakos Drivas, Athanasios Balafoutis and Stelios Rozakis.They look at the research output from their own institution, the Agricultural University of Athens, and relate this output to a range of sources of research funding.They find that funding produces publications
Source: Prometheus
Language: Spanish
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W4233960055
Cites:
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10