Work

Editorial

Year: 2000
Type: editorial
Abstract: The editors often seek to put together an issue with some kind of theme or link between the papers. Despite the fact that the papers available for any particular issue are relatively random having taken their own, sometimes meandering, route through the submission, refereeing, revision and acceptance process. The fact that a theme often emerges is perhaps surprising. However, in this issue the editors have not been able to achieve this and we have a set of, for us, quite separate papers, indicating the wide-ranging nature of the information systems discipline. Nevertheless, they all exhibit quality and relevance in their own ways and, as a test of your insight, we leave the reader to find their own links and themes. The first paper in this issue is by Olaf Henfridsson, and it addresses the issue of ambiguity and sense-making in IT adaptation. Essentially, it concerns the way that IT systems and artefacts are used, viewed, perceived and adapted as a product of social action. It describes an interpretive case study of a social services department in Sweden, and it explores the way that information technology is adapted and readapted in practice in the organization. Sense-making processes are about interpreting and understanding the technology by the individual and the organization. They build on deeply imbedded attention structures that can be both enabling and restricting for how IT is adapted. In the case, the enabling aspect resulted in the technology being used to reduce the administrative workload but was restricting in that it did not really fulfil its potential to be more fully integrated into the existing social services work practices and to have an impact on the way that social services could be delivered. It was used to enhance the existing ways of working administratively but not to impact the social work core or nature, as it was perceived that social work was not about technology. The case itself is interesting, but the approach to the illumination of meaning and sense-making is also worth a close read. The next paper by Nuno Melão and Michael Pidd addresses the topic of business process modelling and provides a conceptual framework for organizing different views of those processes. The authors identify a surprising lack of agreement about the nature of business process and suggest that this is inhibiting our ability to model such processes. The framework adopts four business process themes or perspectives. The first two are essentially metaphors of business processes and the second two are viewpoints. The first is business processes as deterministic machines, that is the notion of tasks performed by human ‘machines’ to convert input into outputs. The second is business processes as complex dynamic machines, where the metaphor is that of the organism, flux and transformation. The third is business processes as interacting feedback loops, similar to the second perspective but with closed loops and intrinsic control. The final perspective is business processes as social constructs, i.e. with people, values, expectations and agendas as the focus of the perspective. The perspectives are developed from literature and practice, and demonstrate the fundamental differences that exist in people’s notions of business processes. The authors argue that understanding this is key in business process modelling and that the different perspectives might lead to different implementation techniques and tools. The third paper by Jan Damsgaard and Rens Scheepers also proposes a four-stage model or perspective but this time for intranet implementation and management, which, as it is demonstrated, exhibit quite different characteristics and use and require different implementation to traditional IT systems. The paper also indicates how to progress through the stages with each stage having seven characteristics, an enhancement of the Stages of Growth Model. Further, the authors argue, in order to ensure intranet institutionalization, three existential crises must be overcome. These ‘crises’ are basically key challenges that must be overcome in each stage before the organization can progress to the next stage. The first challenge relates to sufficient resources and the presence of a sponsor, the second to the need for critical mass of content and users, and the third to procedures and commitment to updating the content. The model looks to be highly relevant, practical and a useful contribution to an area that abounds in hype and generalization. The final paper by Donald Day extends a debate in the literature of systems developers’ attitudes and behaviour in relation to their use of CASE tools. A previous paper by Day concluded that developers’ attitudes towards constraints and their perception of constraint significantly affected their satisfaction with, and their use of, CASE tools. Essentially developers did not like being constrained by tools that made them do things in particular ways, e.g. allowing only top-down design. Venkatesh suggested that variations in the activity (phases or tasks) could have been responsible for some of the observed findings. In this paper, Day tests the contention by including phase and task parameters and concludes that phase and task did not appear to play a mediating role between attitude and behaviour, except possibly to a small degree in the implementation tasks. The study strengthens the validity of the original findings and implies that managers of development involving CASE tools need to pay particular attention to the choice of CASE tool and to the attitudes of developers concerning that tool. It might imply that considerable effort should by made to understand the tool and its role and influencing the perception of the developers using the tool. More successful use of CASE tools should be the result. The research method of the study is also of interest as an exemplar of this type of research.
Language: Spanish
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4237481724
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10