Year: 2016
Type: editorial
Abstract: This issue marks the end of my tenure as an editor-in-chief of Information Systems Journal (ISJ). As of January 2017, ISJ management will adopt a single editor-in-chief model with Robert Davison filling that position. So writing this editorial provides me with an opportunity to reflect on the experience of helping to lead and shape the journal over the past 5 years. When Robert, Philip and I took on the editorial leadership of ISJ in 2012, we signaled both continuity and change. In our first editorial in July 2012, we expressed our intention to continue the spirit of the founding editors, David Avison and Guy Fitzgerald, by fostering high quality and cutting-edge research. But whereas the original vision of cutting-edge research held by David and Guy was methodological, we endeavoured to broaden that understanding. Hence, we encouraged both qualitative/interpretive and quantitative/positivist research. We also encouraged the exploration of cutting-edge and perhaps, risky, information system topics. In addition, we introduced demographic diversity. Collectively, we represent three different regions of the world and gender diversity. We built upon this to broaden the base of not only manuscript contributors but also of senior editors, associate editors and reviewers. Through editorial meetings at conferences and visits to universities, we engaged in a grass roots effort to broaden the base of participation in the journal. Another change we introduced was to focus the editorial process on developmental reviewing. The intention with this approach to reviewing is to determine whether or not a path to publication is possible. If so, the review process would focus on working with the authors to realize that potential. In conjunction with this effort, we have held senior and associate editor workshops about conducting developmental reviews. As part of this effort, we also changed the decision categories to better reflect this intention. We have added a ‘Revise and Resubmit’ decision category to employ when the editors see a possible path to publication. One of my personal goals as editor-in-chief was to further the diversity and inclusiveness of ISJ – in all respects. As I reflect on the past 5 years, I can see the progress that we have made. We have addressed this goal by reaching out beyond the comfort of our own networks to identify and recruit advisory board members, senior editors and associate editors that better reflect the diversity of the information systems academic community. The pursuit of inclusiveness has meant actively working to achieve greater gender, geographical, language of origin, methodological and topical diversity within the editorial ranks. We have also worked to achieve greater diversity of ISJ authorship. Presenting a more diverse editorial team is one signal to potential authors. Another has been our use of special issues. We have actively recruited special issues that deal with emerging topics or ones that have been regularly positioned on the periphery of the field. Further, we have established a policy of enabling special issues to extend beyond one physical issue if there is a sufficient number of high quality papers to warrant doing so. I am proud to have been of service to the information systems academic community through my editorship of ISJ and look forward to continuing my contribution in a different role as a member of the editorial advisory board. The paper by Craig (2016) exemplifies the goal of enhancing gender diversity in the information systems field. It provides results of an under investigated aspect of gender and IS research: evaluation of intervention programmes. In particular, she explores the under theorization of intervention programmes and the difficulties this produces for subsequent evaluation. The research was undertaken in three phases. First, a conceptual framework for intervention programme evaluation was developed from the literature. Second, case studies of 14 intervention programmes in Australia were conducted. Finally, a modification of the framework resulted from the case studies and feedback from intervention programme developers. She found that very few of these developers could articulate the specific problem that their programmes were meant to address. The results demonstrate the need to incorporate evaluation into intervention programmes, which includes articulation of the problem and verification that it has been remediated. The failure to articulate underlying assumptions about what the programmes are expected to address, she concludes, reveals their atheoretical nature. In contrast, the dissemination of sound evaluation results will enable a deeper theorization of the issues surrounding gender and computing interventions. The paper by Park et al. (2016) is about winner's regret in online auctions. This concept is defined as the subjective assessment by consumers in online auctions who get so caught up with winning an auction that they end up overpaying for an item. The authors consider the conundrum of impulsive decision making in the face of humans' unique ability for planned behaviour. Using an automatic thinking perspective as a theoretical lens, they explored this topic in the context of online consumer-to-consumer auctions. Their objective was to understand the extent to which emotional and cognitive triggers of automatic thinking help to predict winner's regret and the extent to which the relationship between these automatic thinking triggers and winner's regret are moderated by competition intensity. A survey of 301 online consumer-to-consumer auction participants was used to examine trait impulsiveness and sunk cost as emotional and cognitive triggers for winners' regret. Their results do, indeed, reveal the significant influence of these factors on winner's regret. The paper by Xu et al. (2016) is also focused on the influence of emotion in online communities, but in a different way. This work is concerned with the impact of aggressive behaviour. The particular context is Chinese users' aggression intention in online social networking communities. The authors were interested in better understanding factors that can affect aggressive online behaviour. To do so, the authors developed a two-part survey that was disseminated to users of a social network community in China. The first part of the survey captured users' beliefs and attitudes about aggression and deterrents. The second part of the survey used scenarios to capture respondents' internet aggression intention. The results of their study show that aggression can be inhibited by two deterrents: face saving and moral beliefs. They found that these deterrents could be enhanced through peer pressure. They also found that age had a differential influence on the deterrents. For those respondents over the age of 30, peer pressure was a significant deterrent; for those younger than 30, it was not.
Source: Information Systems Journal
DOI: 10.1111/isj.12128
Author: Eileen M. Trauth
Language: Spanish
Subfield: Library and Information Sciences
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4238237868
